Time to move on to Shiny Days. I played most of the routes I wanted to see, but I left a few undone so I can pick up the game again later. Now I've played enough to judge all the girls:
My question for the forum: is there a route where Kotonoha does paizuri? Either this game or Shiny Days. I've played half the game and haven't seen one yet.
I like your genuine opinions regarding the girls, I feel somewhat the same way but I just want to express a slightly difference of opinion on Kotonoha. I appreciate her character a little more and I don't mean that in a shy/ timid way, she's reserved, honest and I guess you could call it "conservative", but not (because obviously she's willing to go all the way), she's more flawed as a human showing that she is more relatable as opposed to Sekai or Setsuna.
What I hate more is Makoto and his actions/ choices always depicting him as expressing this lack of personality by this clear evil intentioned level of narcissism. He's depicted as this stud that all the girls want but he's genuinely undeserving of having the interest & infatuation of any of them, making all of the girls feel less genuine and more cliche. Makoto feels more to me like a shallow effort of making the character relatable, where every bad thing that happens to him is more than well deserved. Basically, Makoto makes all men look bad as if the author who created the character could not depict a genuine male protagonist character as being seen in a humane or humanized light -- especially since every other male character is also written to be depicted as this absolute scumbag who are all willing to commit rape even though they should clearly be able to tell a difference between right and wrong because they're all in High School, they should know better.
But despite that I always felt like all the girls deserved a happier ending. Just not with Makoto. Makoto way too often is depicted as a "This ain't my fault/ ain't my problem" type of dude who just doesn't take responsibility even when events are happening as a direct result because of him.
But that's just me. My opinion probably sucks but that's the way I've always seen it, Setsuna is still Best Girl and Sekai comes second, Kotonoha is probably behind the twins but that's only just because of a personal preference for not getting my head chopped off. lol