I just did a quick search on this game and apparently my last post was all the way back in December 2019. It's not like I was constantly posting shit about your games. My previous posts in this thread have also been mostly positive. I was more critical toward Picture Perfect, but my post there was all the way back in January 2020 (six months ago) that I don't even remember what I posted about anymore (I saw it and it was about the stupid headphone in the bath lol). I definitely didn't expect to leave that much impression to you that you kept me in mind even after six months.
I usually don't bother posting about silly things that I can somewhat ignore. The last two things I mentioned (headphone in PP and controller in SS) are just because how jarring they are. I don't expect porn games to be extra realistic, but as I mentioned earlier, it's about the context. Just because it's unrealistic doesn't mean that it has to be not believable. I think what you said about wanting to have fun makes sense, but I also think it isn't great if those are the choices you ended up taking. It's your game though, so you're free to do what you want.
But to answer your question, SS is better than PP because SS actually tries to have a plot and acceptable plot is something that is at least required to be likeable to me. PP is just for the girls as it has no plot.