Not if she took the pill or got fixed after Abby...
He swore to Jessica that he would protect Abby and for him it means to protect her also from himself...
Last edited:
- Thread starter Crazygamer43
- Start date
- Dec 1, 2019
- 8,766
- 14,877
I mean we had that argument before and everything has been analysed and said, but as they say, not by everybody.
In my opinion this is unlikely for a meta reason as well, namely that this game - or its story - make a point out of being what it seems like being. Our daughters not only are claimed to be above 18 as in some other games, they need to be for the story to work. They are not "adopted" because of skipping patreon or other rules, but for the story to work. Granted, a hidden "bio dad" wouldn't kill that at all because the story runs on their official relationship, however, I would consider it more likely that a story element was introduced which forbids Becky to be Frank's son, than that a surprise (or not-so-surprise to those who theoreticize differently) come out later on that she actually is his bio daughter.
Though my guess as well as yours is that it won't be addressed at all. And to reiterate something I said before: I still think that CNG never paid as much attention to the exact timeline as some here do (which is not meant as a criticism of the speculation whatsoever, collecting clues and speculation is fun in fictional stories).
Didn't he mention to Becca in the hotel that Jessica was on the pill? I remember him saying he never used a condom and I think I remember him saying that Jessica was on the pill but Shannon wasn't. And he said that he got extremely "lucky" that Shannon never got pregnant while they were in high school because of that. Which I take as a huge hint that she did get pregnant making him Becca's father.
- Feb 20, 2019
- 1,643
- 4,486
And in case Frank does fire full loads, what if Beth ends up giving birth to twins or something like that. And Abby, Lilly and Becca are planning to have multiple children, if I recall some details in a certain conversation (but I can't recall which one of them wanted to have which exact number of boys and girls).
- Nov 14, 2017
- 66,681
- 33,612
we will have same debate in the future too.
why twins would be bad? they have enuf money to support those.
- Feb 20, 2019
- 1,643
- 4,486
It'd be a surprise if Beth had them (and for Frank). Didn't said it was a bad thing. That could be some twist, since the comment I was replying to said it'd be one if he fired blanks after agreeing to help her having a child (another one could be Beth becoming a mother of triplets).
- Jun 20, 2022
- 6,281
- 10,462
If Frank gives Beth more than one kid in the first go, then they'll be a family feud in 30 years ... probably not relevant to the game though.
- Feb 24, 2021
- 771
- 3,808
New progress report was just posted on Discord - estimated release date June 15th:
Noice.
That seems fast, doesn't it? I probably missed the sneak peek too.
Looks like it. 1.23 came out 21 April, whereas 1.22 was late December. Looks like CNG has got the balance ideal atm
- Jun 14, 2019
- 184
- 387
- Apr 2, 2020
- 801
- 1,044
Handsome. Do you think we will finally see a little action with Abby? The last update ended with a start of "approach" with Lilyth and Abby together. will they go on? I can't wait
- Nov 14, 2017
- 66,681
- 33,612
abby is final boss and i think no things with her on maingame until mc impregnates beth.
- Feb 23, 2018
- 107
- 187
Used this update to restart. Still enjoying it a lot. Just one thing that bothers me especially since you see it more and more in other VNs: Don't put in choices you don't want people to take and then ignore them.
In my case I rejected Beth every single time, no peaking no nothing. Later dialogues still treat it as if banged every single time.
So either give us the choice to say no and treat it as such or simply do not make it a selection.
In my case I rejected Beth every single time, no peaking no nothing. Later dialogues still treat it as if banged every single time.
So either give us the choice to say no and treat it as such or simply do not make it a selection.
- Aug 8, 2017
- 24,153
- 16,603
- Dec 1, 2019
- 8,766
- 14,877
I could think of quite a few reasons, and possibly originally it was intended to make it possible but now the story narrowed down a bit (some stuff wouldn't work without a special connection to Beth I think, or at the very least be even more implausible than it already is).
And I can sympathize, I stopped a different game (to have no discussions about the merits of any individual character from here) where you can turn down (almost?) everybody, however those who I picked didn't seem to have gotten the message at all and dialogue is wonky as well. I wouldn't even have minded too much if they were enforced in the first place, but getting a choice, making it, and then ignoring it is - except for rare circumstances where it becomes immediately clear that you'll have to go a certain route - offputting and distracting.
Since I didn't reject Beth here I cannot say though how it is handled and whether it even may be a bug and not the "canon occurence".
Last edited: