- Dec 1, 2019
- 8,897
- 15,018
Indeed "???". Melody isn't a character from Dating My Daughter (correct name of the game) but from, who'd'a thunk, Melody. And there is no similarity with characters here nor a crossover whatsoever.
- Thread starter Crazygamer43
- Start date
- Jan 2, 2023
- 1,956
- 2,802
its probably a reaction in the wrong thread,whit some confusion about dev's using the same assets
Its 50/50 on that one. If you look at how old Becca is and work backwards to when she must have been conceived, Frank was sleeping with Shannon. Is there a chance she was cheating? Yes. Is there a chance he could be Becca's father? Also yes. It is also entirely possible, given how much planning Becca has done, that she crunched the numbers and figured out who her father was. She has said she has finished other steps in her plan that she can't tell him about yet, that could be one of them. So, yeah, he could be her real dad, he might not be her real dad. We just have to wait and see.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 11,983
- 29,055
It's not 50/50 and there is nothing to wait and see about.
- Mar 28, 2021
- 4,976
- 9,220
You can entertain that idea all you want it won't be confirmed in the game anyway, the dev ain't stupid. He is toeing the line as it is with the patreon rules.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 11,983
- 29,055
Who isn't in this...what exactly is your point you're trying to make? Is that this is refreshing because they are custom and everyone and their uncle's brother's sister's second cousin's former roommate's dog has used the Dee model?
There is no evidence to suggest he definitely isn't. It would fit in perfectly with the already established lore of the game, regardless of what Patreon says. If CNG wants to do that, it could be the final update. We won't know until CNG tells us who her father is. The only thing we know for certain is it can't be Trevor (Lillith's father). Shannon met him for the first time after Becca was born.
- Jan 12, 2021
- 1,687
- 2,742
In real life terms, I would say that Frank is the prime suspect. On this subject, I can recommend the novel Homo faber by the Swiss writer Max Frisch.
But to keep CNG out of trouble from Patreon, I think her father is some random who once had an act with a drunk Shannon at a girls' night out.
But to keep CNG out of trouble from Patreon, I think her father is some random who once had an act with a drunk Shannon at a girls' night out.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 70,122
- 35,598
yes, all pieces fit but like you said dev won't tell ever (unless moves to subs and makes uncensored version).
We already know that Shannon and Frank threw a wild party, followed by a sex marathon nine months before Becca happened. We don't need to invent some offstage event.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 70,122
- 35,598
yes but we also know that shannon was slut so she could been preggo before mc and she had sex.
- Mar 22, 2021
- 31
- 28
It wouldnt surprise me if Frank the MC was firing blanks, he is not Abi's biological dad, nor Lillith's, it is possible he could be Becca's but not confirmed. So it is possible but unlikely story wise as he is being considered as the sperm donor of the lesbian couples (Sorry cant remember the names right now) child.
- Jun 20, 2022
- 6,780
- 11,294
He can't be either of their dad ... he wasn't there. The fact that Jessica never got pregnant again is more relevant than anything in your argument.
- Mar 22, 2021
- 31
- 28
I know he cant be their dad as my post said "he is not abi's dad" etc. Sorry if I misunderstood the first part of your reply, but I do agree that Jessica failing to get pregnant again add's some weight to it.
- Jun 20, 2022
- 6,780
- 11,294
I guess my point was including the fact that he isn't Abi or Lilly's bio-dad wasn't really relevant to YOUR argument ... your initial post implied that they not being his kids was relevant to him possibly being sterile.
I honestly feel 50/50 about this. It would be a major twist if he did try to get Beth pregnant and then they found out he's firing blanks.
- Aug 25, 2022
- 1,129
- 1,706
if he's the real dad that would definetively break the "i can't do abby" bcs, well, he did his daughter :V
Not if she took the pill or got fixed after Abby...
He swore to Jessica that he would protect Abby and for him it means to protect her also from himself...
Last edited:
- Dec 1, 2019
- 8,897
- 15,018
I mean we had that argument before and everything has been analysed and said, but as they say, not by everybody.
In my opinion this is unlikely for a meta reason as well, namely that this game - or its story - make a point out of being what it seems like being. Our daughters not only are claimed to be above 18 as in some other games, they need to be for the story to work. They are not "adopted" because of skipping patreon or other rules, but for the story to work. Granted, a hidden "bio dad" wouldn't kill that at all because the story runs on their official relationship, however, I would consider it more likely that a story element was introduced which forbids Becky to be Frank's son, than that a surprise (or not-so-surprise to those who theoreticize differently) come out later on that she actually is his bio daughter.
Though my guess as well as yours is that it won't be addressed at all. And to reiterate something I said before: I still think that CNG never paid as much attention to the exact timeline as some here do (which is not meant as a criticism of the speculation whatsoever, collecting clues and speculation is fun in fictional stories).
Didn't he mention to Becca in the hotel that Jessica was on the pill? I remember him saying he never used a condom and I think I remember him saying that Jessica was on the pill but Shannon wasn't. And he said that he got extremely "lucky" that Shannon never got pregnant while they were in high school because of that. Which I take as a huge hint that she did get pregnant making him Becca's father.