e6mill

Forum Fanatic
Aug 4, 2022
4,551
9,152
628
It's obvious that he's still suffering from what happened and he's never had time to work through it with little Abby because she needed him at the time.
It's not the sort of thing you "work through". It doesn't go away. All you can do is cherish the happy memories.
 

rudy007

Engaged Member
Mar 17, 2021
2,647
7,421
637
I agree. Personally, I see the “Is Frank Becca's father?” point more under the light: he's at least more likely than Trevor, for whom the time frame absolutely doesn't add up. Other than that, I personally don't really care and your last sentence sums it up well.

Another topic: What would you guys like Single Again to cover that is not sex-specific? For me it would be, in no specific order:

Abby meeting her half-siblings at least once. However, without the father present and thus only Abby, Frank, the 3 kids and their mother present.

Lilly confronting her father and giving him a piece of her mind. Yes, Abby had that too, but the trauma from her father was a formative event for Lilly for a long time and even though she's over it, I think it would be good for her.

Frank talking to Vanessa about the death of his wife. It's obvious that he's still suffering from what happened and he's never had time to work through it with little Abby because she needed him at the time.
Agree, I would like them to meet Crystal again. Or MC's parents, they did good things in the past... Well, not Oli... If he's not apologize to the girls, we leave Lillith for a short chat wit him...:ROFLMAO:
 
  • Thinking Face
  • Like
Reactions: Elhemeer and MrLKX

MrLKX

Well-Known Member
Jan 12, 2021
1,762
2,869
397
Agree, I would like them to meet Crystal again. Or MC's parents, they did good things in the past... Well, not Oli... If he's not apologize to the girls, we leave Lillith for a short chat wit him...:ROFLMAO:
I would say that Lilly's reaction has made enough of an impression on Oli that he behaves himself from now on.

Since you mentioned Crystal, she and Frank were relatively close and she never liked Shannon. I'm seriously surprised that she and Frank never talked about what happened during the divorce over the phone. That could have given us an idea of her opinion of Becca and Lilly.
 

rudy007

Engaged Member
Mar 17, 2021
2,647
7,421
637
I would say that Lilly's reaction has made enough of an impression on Oli that he behaves himself from now on.

Since you mentioned Crystal, she and Frank were relatively close and she never liked Shannon. I'm seriously surprised that she and Frank never talked about what happened during the divorce over the phone. That could have given us an idea of her opinion of Becca and Lilly.
Yes, I would like to see this reunion. It would round up nicely the whole story. Perhaps for a holiday, the whole family...
 

Adhdclassic

Forum Fanatic
Mar 10, 2024
5,265
8,175
649
Events that would fun.
1. Lily knocks out Trevor.
2. Rebecca knocks out Shannon(especially if she finds out frank is her father)
3. Frank knocks up Liz
4. Abigails mom visits Frank in a dream
5. Abigail visits siblings
6. Rebecca fucks Vanessa while Frank fucks Liz
7. They all reveal that they are together to Abigail. She's cool with it, but mad they kept it a secret.
 

Elhemeer

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 20, 2022
7,833
13,171
812
Events that would fun.
1. Lily knocks out Trevor.
2. Rebecca knocks out Shannon(especially if she finds out frank is her father)
3. Frank knocks up Liz
4. Abigails mom visits Frank in a dream
5. Abigail visits siblings
6. Rebecca fucks Vanessa while Frank fucks Liz
7. They all reveal that they are together to Abigail. She's cool with it, but mad they kept it a secret.
I think 7 has to be more substantial than that. I expect the progress to becoming a "all-lovers" family to have much variety of emoting from everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rudy007

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
76,573
39,434
1,519
4. was done on other avn (before daddy fucked daughter) and while it worked it was weird.
 

Dr. Mick

Active Member
Nov 21, 2017
517
1,151
240
Events that would fun.
1. Lily knocks out Trevor.
2. Rebecca knocks out Shannon(especially if she finds out frank is her father)
3. Frank knocks up Liz
4. Abigails mom visits Frank in a dream
5. Abigail visits siblings
6. Rebecca fucks Vanessa while Frank fucks Liz
7. They all reveal that they are together to Abigail. She's cool with it, but mad they kept it a secret.
Agreed; several of these would be fun.
  1. I'd like to see Lilith come face-to-face with Trevor, talk with him for a bit, realize he's a useless piece of shit, watch her ball up her fist, then get ready to walk away - only to have him say one last stupid thing, and deck him, knocking him flat.
  2. It would be more satisfying to see Becca take her down verbally; with a calculated comeback for everything Shannon might try to use against her. With how vindictive Shannon is, there would have to be proof that she started an altercation between them, so that Becca was safe from any retaliation. Then Shannon crosses the line, and gets backhanded.
  3. When you say Liz, do you mean Beth? If so, that's already coming if you have chosen that route.
  4. Could be interesting. Have seen it in other VNs and it can work if done well. If Jess visits the way the fairy versions of the girls do in his dreams, that might be fun, though a little strange.
  5. Much later in the story perhaps. The secondary footnote with her half siblings could be a couple frames in a recap just to say that they reached out to each other and text sometimes.
  6. This very well could happen, and even seems to have been subtly hinted at. Considering the relationship agreement that Beth and Nessa have, and the nature of Becca and Frank's, I'd say it's rather likely. Although, considering recent events, and the rewrite that happened, the likelihood dropped considerably.
  7. Add, "and that they didn't include her sooner" to the end of that and you have what will probably happen, eventually.
Most of that is hypothetical, and just my speculative opinion obviously.
 

Maviarab

Doing Mafia Helmet Things....
Donor
Jul 12, 2020
14,407
35,638
997
Another topic: What would you guys like Single Again to cover that is not sex-specific?
Honestly, consider me dull at parties...but nothing that anyone has covered. Leave the past where it has...no need for more drama, meeting people...people getting 'closure'....

Just get on with the story and get it finished...we're almost at 5 years ongoing now.
 

ccxvidonaferens

Active Member
May 25, 2022
791
993
217
Bottom line here folks is some people are so utterly obsessed with incest that they will jump through hoops to make it believable and see what they want to see. I worry about them.

I find it ridiculous that some people, knowing exactly what type of character Shannon is, refuse to believe she wouldn't fuck anything with 2 legs, drunk, sober, whether she in a relationship or not and that she would cheat ona character (personality) like Frank in a heartbeat or jump from one 'lover' to another in the blink of an eye.

As always though, time will tell the truth.
Not entirely sure she would limit herself to two legs, to be honest.
 

Hammerhiem

Member
May 7, 2020
283
543
277
Events that would fun.
1. Lily knocks out Trevor.
2. Rebecca knocks out Shannon(especially if she finds out frank is her father)
3. Frank knocks up Liz
4. Abigails mom visits Frank in a dream
5. Abigail visits siblings
6. Rebecca fucks Vanessa while Frank fucks Liz
7. They all reveal that they are together to Abigail. She's cool with it, but mad they kept it a secret.
1. I'm not a fan of casual female on male violence, especially the idea that a skinny tiny girl is going to drop a fully grown man, a slap is as far as it would go and i would hate even that.

2. Again why with the violence? as Othershave said a verbal beatdown is more Becca

3. That's fairly certain.

4. Nah, this isn't "Light of my life" Becca is his concience not his long dead wife.

5. This should be an extended story arc, Abi coming to love her half siblings fits her character and teh wholesome nature of teh VN, unlike randomly punching people.

6. A foursome would be sweet, especially if it means we avoid a Lily/becca threesome.

7. That would be fitting.
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
76,573
39,434
1,519
1. I'm not a fan of casual female on male violence, especially the idea that a skinny tiny girl is going to drop a fully grown man, a slap is as far as it would go and i would hate even that.
glass jaw.
 

MrLKX

Well-Known Member
Jan 12, 2021
1,762
2,869
397
Well, Lilly doesn't have a reputation for having a nasty right hook for nothing.

1. she broke the nose of a classmate who was bullying Abby and was suspended for it because Frank stood up for her, otherwise she would probably have been expelled from school.

2. she punched Abby's cousin for grabbing her (my sympathy for Abby's cousin is limited and I don't think even his mother, Crystal, has much sympathy for her son on that one)

3. she gave Frank a nasty black eye. Without knowing the context of what happened to Lilly in that case, I think it's understandable that she reacted that way.

But yes, I think a character grown Lilly doesn't need to pull out a hook for her father. Unless he grabs her by the shoulder and tries to talk her down, then go ahead girl.

At this point I'll throw in the sports and fitness offers in the apartment building they all live in. Frank could definitely take Lilly there so that she can burn off some energy and perhaps learn a thing or two about self-control, discipline and patience.
 

Hammerhiem

Member
May 7, 2020
283
543
277
glass jaw.
I've seem the dweebiest of Dwebs take a full shot of a girl and barely even flinch, Biology is a thing.

If lilly was a trained fighter she "might" have a chance of hurting him, but she's not she a tiny skinny girl.

Which is why society excuses female violence, and abused men suffer in silence.
 

Elhemeer

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 20, 2022
7,833
13,171
812
1. I'm not a fan of casual female on male violence, especially the idea that a skinny tiny girl is going to drop a fully grown man, a slap is as far as it would go and i would hate even that.
IF this scene was to happen, in what world could any confrontation between them be considered "casual" ... Do you consider the event that gave Frank a shiner to be "casual" violence?

The seeds have been sowed for a Trevor/Lilly confrontation and it would be completely out of character for her not to take a swing at him at this point. That doesn't mean she'll knock him out, or ever knock him down. Or that she'd even be able to reach his head -- a groin shot would actually be more likely I'd think.

Regardless, it won't be a casual encounter, and it'll be up to the storytelling whether it'll feel like it was done well or not.

That said, I agree that Becca is unlikely to attack Shannut physically, but I would 100% expect them to have a "violent" verbal confrontation.
 

ArDZer

Well-Known Member
Feb 20, 2019
1,928
5,511
698
IF this scene was to happen, in what world could any confrontation between them be considered "casual" ... Do you consider the event that gave Frank a shiner to be "casual" violence?

The seeds have been sowed for a Trevor/Lilly confrontation and it would be completely out of character for her not to take a swing at him at this point. That doesn't mean she'll knock him out, or ever knock him down. Or that she'd even be able to reach his head -- a groin shot would actually be more likely I'd think.

Regardless, it won't be a casual encounter, and it'll be up to the storytelling whether it'll feel like it was done well or not.

That said, I agree that Becca is unlikely to attack Shannut physically, but I would 100% expect them to have a "violent" verbal confrontation.
It must be remembered that Becca did had Justin and his female coworker beaten up and fired from their jobs after Lilly was left heartbroken. It could be a possible scenario if Shannon ends up losing her manager position at that fast food joint she works for, courtesy from her eldest pissed off daughter (and the incident wouldn't be traced back to Becca in any way).
 
  • Like
Reactions: rudy007

Elhemeer

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 20, 2022
7,833
13,171
812
It must be remembered that Becca did had Justin and his female coworker beaten up and fired from their jobs after Lilly was left heartbroken. It could be a possible scenario if Shannon ends up losing her manager position at that fast food joint she works for, courtesy from her eldest pissed off daughter (and the incident wouldn't be traced back to Becca in any way).
Oh, that's totally possible. She could even end up in jail for embezzlement and have no idea what happened to her ... but Becca's not going to do anything out in the open like was being speculated/hoped for in the original post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rudy007 and ArDZer
3.70 star(s) 234 Votes