You can earn both Girlfriend and Fucktoy in the same save, no problem.For anyone trying to achievement hunt, and dislikes reading backlogs, there are six achievements as of version 1.6.
1. Girlfriend: Alyssa must have a three level difference between Affection and Obedience in favor of Affection.
.2 Fucktoy: Alyssa must have a three level difference between Affection and Obedience in favor of Obedience.
-You cannot earn both 1 and 2 on one save file, so you need two different runs to earn them
3. Submissive: Maximize Alyssa's Affection and Obedience.
4. Jealous 1: Through your original slave, initiate either Sex or Anal. Completely ignore Alyssa and only perform actions with your Original Slave. Do this Five times and then speak to Alyssa. Decline her invitation for sex.
5. Jealous 2: Through your original slave, initiate either Sex or Anal. Completely ignore your Original Slave and only perform actions with Alyssa. Do this Five times and then speak to your Original Slave. Decline her invitation for sex.
-You can initiate sex with your Original Slave both before and after you leave the house, or after Sex or Anal training. Both can be earned on the same save file.
6. Slave Pair: Maximize both Alyssa's Affection and Obedience, and your Original Slave's Training while Minimizing her Resistance.
Step 1. Do not punish her under any circumstance, avoid obedience. Simply give her love until you reach Rank 3 earning Girlfriend.
Step 2. Stop giving her love of any kind and only punish, preferably punish without her having earned it such as slapping her for making cupcakes. This will lover her trust. Also, spank her hard and a a lot. Keep doing this and when you reach Rank 4 or 5 Obedience, you will gain Fucktoy in addition to Girlfriend.
Step 3. Profit. Whatever you do now she will gain both Trust and Obedience. So just have fun.