Haha, I actually liked the originals with the over-the-top expressions and eyes, along with the boobs. They're supposed to be cartoons. But hey, as you said, can't please everyone.
Hoping for sound, and desperately hoping that this doesn't turn into a slut-trainer, but goes more along the harem route (or at least gives us the option, rather than forcing us to lewd the girls out to the public). And I'll echo the preggo vibes earlier in the chat.
One suggestion for now is to actively put an end message or something for the demo. I spent an extra half-hour trying to find Sam at the library until I realized that's not in the game yet. Also, the language and dialogue is sorta meh for me ... style and typos make it fairly obvious you're ESL (my apologies if you're not).
Anyway, looks great. Fingers crossed this gets finished and doesn't end up in dev hell or abandoned like so many highly-anticipated games. Keep it simple, and finish the game, as you can obviously see you've got lots of interest for this.