Damn glad I finally gave in and tried this game, it really is top notch, for all the good reasons, the renders, honestly think the MC is great, all the girls (except Serena, unless Ines took her place, something has to happen for her cause her spot on the banner is kind of unwarranted) have something special, on top of being beautiful, Alistair actually is a great 'sidekick', they all deal with some kind of trauma (a personal 'kink' of mine I guess, if they deal with some shit and it's well-written, love that), animations are 'meh' but I definitely don't enjoy this game for them so I don't care.
Yeah, top game for sure.
Edit: I may have written that little review before actually getting into chapter 5, animations are way better in this chapter than they were before.