Nicole never fucks anyone else. Instead she discovers she's a cuckquean and gets turned on at hearing about the mc sleeping with other women. I also did you get the Mom and the Aunt mixed up? Ashley never handcuffs you. It's her sister that's more into all the kinky stuff like that.
I didn't confuse the Aunt and the mom. When i picked the mom, the Aunt path closed, so i imagine they are exclusive. On the mom's path, when she sent the MC to get the box containing her stripper clothes in the hotel room she used, the MC finds handcuffs, blindfold and mention she must be very kinky. If you say Trisha handcuffs you, i guess both sisters are in this type of stuff.
Also dude you need to chill. Kind of sound like you reject any LI who had any sort of history with other guys, None of the girls really sleep around in the first place. Idk most of the reasons why you rejected or wanted to reject the LI just sound weird to me. Like I don't get why you should really care if the sister went to a party or not but that's just my opinion
So, my opinions are bad and shitty, but yours are the only good ones? You must be a riot IRL with that attitude. Not that your opinion is better than mine or vice versa, as its called an OPINION, but you could at least have put some reasons why you thought differently on some LI's instead of just saying you dont think like me, you weird, yout suck. It just make you sound immature and illeterate.
I can expand on my thoughts and reasonning a bit further. For reference, when i say a LI, i mean a long term relationship type character. Side girls are a different beast, as they are just for extra sex scenes and generally much less present in the game, so it matter much less to me as i can easily just choose to ignore them if i want to and not miss much content .
I don't really reject LI's for their past if i think its a normal past, but i will reject any LI that is a prostitute-type, give the vibe of a 304 or has a past of being the town bicycle. I didnt mind Ashley at first even when she turned the fooling around and kissing dial on, but when she started talking about the past, how after she left the dad she went on to "discover" herself and banged not a few but a ton of dudes in one night stands over 10 years, then i find the kinky toys, i kinda lost interest in her. Similar with the twins. I imagine they are there to be banged around as they state they dont want boyfriends and like to party and have a "good time", but i really hate stealth twinswaps, it disgusts me. I also dont care that MC sister wasnt a virgin. I was just curious to know as a party girl that pass out all the time if she was the town bicycle or not before deciding. She makes you tell the story with Rosa when you loose the game, but refuse to tell you her first or her worst sex encounter if you win. Ahhh Rosa, i wish i could see you again over a coffee
I will also reject LI's if they have character traits i dislike. It's called preferences. Like Nicole. She tells you she want a break, she wants to go fuck random dudes, fake orgasms and dont seem to care to have much sex with the MC. When she said that, for me that was a dead character. Regardless if she does fuck other dudes or not is irrelevant, that fact is she told the MC she wanted to is enough and the trust is broken. If you say she becomes a cuckquean and the NTR arc got scrapped, i assume patrons probably got mad at the idea. If she wouldnt have said that and just be "go help your sister and make some money ill wait for you" and when her sister brought the open relationship she would have said "no, are you crazy", i would have stayed with her. But i understand that games that provides the MC with a girlfriend needs a plot device to separate them. I did prefer she said her intentions and that i could eventually break up of my own choice rather than we just find she cheated or betrayed you for example.
As for most of the other LI's i chose to close paths with, its not necessarily because i dislike them per se. I am mainly a single LI type player, so when i pick one, i usually just close off the rest instead of being the fuckboy and then go by process of elimination of who interest me more. (which is also why i wont do the open relationship route ever) I dont often play harem games as most are just sex scenes simulators. Also, since the game is so big, i for sure will not do all the possibilities. Maybe Veronica, the cousin or Yuki, but i will certainly play 1 more time and do some opposite choices, like picking Trisha over Ashley or going a bit further with the church girl. At worst if i get intrigued, i can always use a gallery unlocker to satisfy my curiosity.
Thats my way of playing those type of games.