Consolidating power? Also do note that in this universe, humanity has evolved to a point where it's stated they can completely cure cancer and other currently incurable diseases. As well as discovered a way to either teleport or create holograms (wasn't clear for me in the scene between Xanthe and the Aldain's), and assumingly other currently impossible, unfeasible, or immoral tasks. So I don't see it out of scope to assume the government has some way to consistently intercept things they don't want being released to the public, which also should've technically negated the release of the video of the fight between MC and Kenny, so I would call that a plot hole if my guesswork is correct.
At this point in development, yes, I do agree with most of this. However, this doesn't mean that a rule currently nonexistent cannot exist in the future. How do we know that Klaus' barrier and anyone else's theoretical barriers don't directly bolster their physical body or act as an extension of it? And even though mcmng clarified that Alice gets eviscerated if you choose to talk to Danica and Oscar in the office, I don't think it's fair to say she dies to Danica under any circumstance at any power level, since she has only been focusing on the offensive aspect of her power up until this point.
As stated before, we don't know the properties of Klaus' barrier, so he could in theory just blast Danica while she's charging her X marks the spot shit. Alexis' body is likely comprised entirely of metal at this point (especially after her forced evolution) so Dani would most likely overestimate her powers effectiveness, do negligible damage, and then just get bopped. Not enough is known about Clark right now. Alice dies at her current power level no matter what. And as for Oscar, his size, and if his 'green light' ability does what I assume (make him really fast) he could probably close the distance and pummel Danica before she can react, otherwise tank any damage due to his sheer size and the proceed with the pummeling.
Well, I feel that only creates an opportunity for more story, it could've just as easily been written as "a bunch of all powerful monsters came to Earth and killed everyone", but there is clearly something more than that going on. And I was basing my theory of Ella (and probably eventually the MC seeing they have similar powers) regenerating their bodies from next to nothing or even a stand of hair, off the fact that DNA (the basis of their powers) can rarely exist in hair. Also vampires from the Witcher universe lol.
Thing is, overwhelming government control and technology able to intercept and control all information on such a level doesn't gel with the state of the world as it is presented to us. The corollaries of such aren't noticeable during the story, hell, it feels like the 2000s with tech specifically advanced in a few select places. And even then, the level of control required to suppress all the potential information breaches is mental. Whistleblowers, hackers, accidental leaks, any amount of actual proof making it out would make a huge deal. If we knew for sure that this info is only limited to Xanthe and his underlings, or fewer people had powers in the first place, it would be much easier to believe.
And what I was trying to get at with the rules as we know them thus far, is that it is impossible for any future reveal of the rule to correct the situation. Because the very first time we see Danica use her special, the cross she creates in MCs body, he has to literally rip out of himself. So it automatically bypasses any armor or natural defensive powers. Like, what the hell can you do in that situation? The only flexibility left in the rules, is whether the power of the attack is determined by the amount of time she prepares it for. And even that might create some holes in the process if established.
Otherwise the only power that could counter it is something that makes you immune to to other powers altogether, which is boring as fuck, and I hope doesn't happen.
In regards to other people trying to fight Danica, this is pointless. For the simple reason that as far as we know nobody except for the MC could even learn how this ability works and how to counter it. And, assuming that the only thing that increases with duration of the attack is size, and the special cuts through anything, which it essentially has been shown to, all she needs is to put a few centimeters of hole into her opponent's vital organs and the fight is done. The element of surprise is on her side, just as it was in most confrontations with the MC, and an ability this powerful will win that in any case.
In terms of power scaling of monsters, yes, that outcome would be boring, but if you made it the most logical outcome instead of whatever actually happens, that's on you. And it is much easier to slip into that when you're raising the power level this much. Something you have to be really careful with.
Also, the Witcher universe has straight up magic, and many various types of ghosts, which prove that consciousness can exist without a physical form in that world. I don't think we've reached that point here.
P.S. Also Witcher 2 has a better story than Witcher 3, and I will fight anyone on that. (And Heart Of Stone is a better DLC out of the two for W3)