The worst part is in chapter one when that actually happens you don't have to do either.
You can follow both routes and choose*not* to continue at multiple points. But despite being either totally faithful or having stirred the pot by cheating with our lesbain best friend, the games second chapter just decides (without warning) its canonical we did the unplanned threesome with Mr Dickhead (or if the other route is coming, but not in game yet, give us a title card saying that). Makes importing a save from first game seem pretty completely pointless.
Likewise we don't get the option to even be flirty with others during the second game. Hot naked rich girl in her own private pool? Our protagonist could have slutted it up the entire previous game and suddenly is a prude. Getting hit on by the Inquisitor we had choice to flirt or reject before? Protagonist rejects her now, no choice. Sleezy bar owner man? Our protagonist again decides for us he's unwlecome (despite sucking Leon off being canonical and *if* you actually did that in the past being able to decide you liked it or not). Even if some choices where just flavor text, or only incremented only a value to track how forwards our character was, it'd be good at making it feel like we where shaping a role in the world, but intead we've been put in the backseat to watch the progonist become a straight steriotyped blond wallflower unable to resist the bigger dicks of "bad men" despite her fiancé (note one e when its a man, too when its the women). I'd overlook it if the "gameplay" was primary over the plot, like this was a horror game or shooter, but its a visual novel porn game, why can't we at least CHOOSE if we wink at somebody?
