Eye of the beholder. I like the character models in TGO just fine.
As far as the story goes, to be honest, I don't like that much the supernatural aspect of this series. LE had a dead zombie priest, that's okay, but Nadia went so over the top, that it affected even the sex scenes drastically. I found the scenes at the temple near the end of the game awful.
TGO has only one magical scene so far (the "floating" threesome). Hopefully, it doesn't go further than that, but I doubt it.
Other than that, William doesn't behave like a proper police officer, but I like him more than Brad and Henry somehow. Probably because of his design and more mature vibe compared to the other two.