Cartageno

Devoted Member
Dec 1, 2019
8,766
14,878
I am a bit on Devian's side here. I especially agree on the twins' situation. Every girl has her own qualities and whom I like most is on the move (admittedly for me as wel Rachel is generally a bit further down the list), even Donna can be redeemed methinks. Some, like Alice, or Charlotte and April are still a bit bland (also sometimes a bit inconsistent, as Aprils attitude towards Cass in her storyline). But Cass I have so far found no way to be too interested in and I was happy when she could suck my dick metaphorically only.

Though the "group hug" was fun :)
 

oceanbobo4

Member
Feb 12, 2021
185
292
Lucy the maid #1

Liz #2

#3 is a tie with all the rest of them, except Harriet and Cassandra (even the new and improved Cassandra . . . though she's a good character and entertaining and funny)

And I want more of that new girl, Arabella

This is about the only game where I'm interested in all the girls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

Cartageno

Devoted Member
Dec 1, 2019
8,766
14,878
Lucy the maid #1

Liz #2

#3 is a tie with all the rest of them, except Harriet and Cassandra (even the new and improved Cassandra . . . though she's a good character and entertaining and funny)

And I want more of that new girl, Arabella

This is about the only game where I'm interested in all the girls.
Not trying to denigrate this opinion, but actually, there are a few games out there where all girls are interesting - maybe not at the same level, but without a "dud".
 
Oct 7, 2020
74
57
For me, Liz is my favorite girl, and Sam is my favorite woman.
Liz is attractive and we have compatible kinks, and Sam is the pretty, shy, nerdy, girl-next-door types, and I just love that.

I like most of them, some for their looks, some for their personalities, some for their kinks, and some with various combinations of the above. Priti is also pretty high on the list, she is just adorable. Amy is fun, but a bit too vanilla for me so far. I love the look of the twins, but their story with Claire is in a really unpleasant place. I am curious to see where Harriet's story goes too. As for Rachel, no offense to her fans, but I like her kink, and that is about it. She isn't physically attractive to me, and her newfound jealousy streak is a real turn off, hopefully she is over that now. With Donna, about the only thing I look forward to there, is breaking her.

About the only one I can't stand is Cass, she has nice tits, and that is about it. I can't stand anything else about her, and I don't foresee anything happening to change my opinion of her. Maybe we could call Willy Wonka, have him turn her into candy, and then at least the other girls can get some pleasure out of her.
Cass Crunchies, get yours today!
I agree with lots (excluding the parts about rachel), Samantha is definitely my favorite out of the women there, I like the way she speaks too, it really accentuates her shy personality, and the slight inferiority complex she has of her sister being the preferred choice for men was just too cute. Cass is in the same place to me, she's okay with her mouth shut but her entire personality besides that is really annoying, I guess thats the point though, I'm open to maybe disliking her less but even debbie has turned out a more loveable character, you have nice taste bro
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian
Oct 7, 2020
74
57
Not trying to denigrate this opinion, but actually, there are a few games out there where all girls are interesting - maybe not at the same level, but without a "dud".
know any with an artstyle similar to this then? This type of art is similar but lots of other games in the same style dont have girls that look like the ones here, HMs girls look more cute than sexy or something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oceanbobo4

Bloodguard

Engaged Member
Feb 20, 2021
2,822
4,389
thanks for the suggestion, I'll check it out.
Harem Hotel was grindy, and had too much politics for a porn game. Also the lewd scenes have no audio, and are boring. Try it if you want, but some good games with this art style, are Now & Then, Once in a Lifetime, A House in the Rift, Waifu Academy, and Pale Carnations. Also Ripples probably has the best looking Honey Select graphics I've seen, but doesn't have much content yet. (y)
 
Oct 7, 2020
74
57
Harem Hotel was grindy, and had too much politics for a porn game. Also the lewd scenes have no audio, and are boring. Try it if you want, but some good games with this art style, are Now & Then, Once in a Lifetime, A House in the Rift, Waifu Academy, and Pale Carnations. Also Ripples probably has the best looking Honey Select graphics I've seen, but doesn't have much content yet. (y)
I'll check them out, the girls in One in a Lifetime and Waifu Academy look really cute, thanks man. I'll check the others out tomorrow too, thanks tons
 

Havik79

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2019
6,767
8,015
I'll check them out, the girls in One in a Lifetime and Waifu Academy look really cute, thanks man. I'll check the others out tomorrow too, thanks tons
Dude ignore him, I am biased, but I supported Harem Hotel for over a year, it is only grindy if you want to boost some of the stats of the girls, and want to get all the scenes, but it is still a great game.
Yes it has politics, while there is a nice and bad route, you are supposed to be a nice guy, and most nice people think slavery is wrong, and seeing as a huge part of the game involves the fact humans enslaved elves, politics does play somewhat of a part.
It's not like the shit we see, it is more about the fact your main love interest is an elf slave, and not being ok with that, more so when you have lots of elves in the game.
As for the lack of sound, is it that big a deal not to hear some guy fingering a jar of mayonnaise for sex sounds.

You cow farms, yeah, the dev of waifu academy puts a large cow milking farm to shame, he is one of the biggest milkers on this site, the only dev I have personally seen worse than him is the dev of Milfy City who took I think almost 18 months between updates, waifu is usually 9 months if not more, and not a huge update.

Ripples have a ton of playtime, and a decent amount of sex, but it is story-driven.

My New Family also has tons of stories and sex, if you are into fucking your sisters, mum, aunt, grandma, cousin, like 50 different women.

Really though this is off topic, and there is a section for recommendations.

As sweet shy sexy little ginger minx Lucy is the best girl in this game.
 
Oct 7, 2020
74
57
Dude ignore him, I am biased, but I supported Harem Hotel for over a year, it is only grindy if you want to boost some of the stats of the girls, and want to get all the scenes, but it is still a great game.
Yes it has politics, while there is a nice and bad route, you are supposed to be a nice guy, and most nice people think slavery is wrong, and seeing as a huge part of the game involves the fact humans enslaved elves, politics does play somewhat of a part.
It's not like the shit we see, it is more about the fact your main love interest is an elf slave, and not being ok with that, more so when you have lots of elves in the game.
As for the lack of sound, is it that big a deal not to hear some guy fingering a jar of mayonnaise for sex sounds.

You cow farms, yeah, the dev of waifu academy puts a large cow milking farm to shame, he is one of the biggest milkers on this site, the only dev I have personally seen worse than him is the dev of Milfy City who took I think almost 18 months between updates, waifu is usually 9 months if not more, and not a huge update.

Ripples have a ton of playtime, and a decent amount of sex, but it is story-driven.

My New Family also has tons of stories and sex, if you are into fucking your sisters, mum, aunt, grandma, cousin, like 50 different women.

Really though this is off topic, and there is a section for recommendations.

As sweet shy sexy little ginger minx Lucy is the best girl in this game.
yeah we veered a bit off-topic there. Lucy is great though, I hope the romance route has a lot more to offer going forward, she definitely has one of the cutest personalities of all the girls there.
 

Havik79

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2019
6,767
8,015
I normally don't give a shit, but I really would love a chance to marry Lucy, she is literally happy to clean your house, very sweet and shy, sexy little exhibitionist, well for us anyway, and fair-skinned pink nipple freckle face ginger, it just doesn't get better.
 

WindIsHowling

Active Member
Aug 5, 2017
579
648
I cant relate to having a flat chest, really, so I dont understand your first point. I don't watch anime either, so I can't comment on the first point. I think she's cute, I'm not objectively evaluating how she was written, I like her design and I like how her story is going so far. Rachel warms up to the headmaster relatively quickly because he helps her 'solve her problem', unrelated to how he does it I think she has some very cute moments (like falling asleep with the HM, napping on his lap, etc), she's cute as fuck because she isn't as cold and doesn't have as many ulterior motives as the other girls, she just wants somewhere she feels safe and can be confident. Though I do wish we got more cute stuff before hopping right into lewd things, I wouldnt mind if she slept with the HM and just held onto him, for example, instead of having to be 'tired out', I admit that might be out of character for the HM though.

whos ur fav girl though?
Just... Lol. Meet a real girl.
 

GamesR4fun

Newbie
Dec 30, 2020
59
19
This game needs an ending where MC just say "Fuk it i wont train these girls to be some rich a-holes wives I will train them to be part of my harem" then he wins the lottery(or just need some other way to get large amounts of cash) buys of the entire school ground and enjoys and expands his harem (also fire that perv[male]teacher and drunk gronds keeper cuz i hate to share :))
ya I agree with the hating to share but I don't remember the game forcing you to share the girls or women with them unless you choose to so I hope they haven't changed that since I played it last
 

Cartageno

Devoted Member
Dec 1, 2019
8,766
14,878
ya I agree with the hating to share but I don't remember the game forcing you to share the girls or women with them unless you choose to so I hope they haven't changed that since I played it last
There is no direct sharing of any kind - nobody except you (and themselves) lays a finger on any of these girls. However, you are constantly broadcasting everything from your office - at least the punishments - to some wealthy fat old bald guys (which could be me except for the wealthy part).
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

Havik79

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2019
6,767
8,015
You don't say.
She could actually be any prostitute doing things for money.
Therefore unless you're open for open relationship, she will probably cheat on you someday by sleeping with a wealthier man than you.
Except she isn't she is only doing these things for us, and doing that would piss off a lot of players, so that ain't going to happen.

Fuck I thought I was a negative person.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheDevian

Living In A Lewd World

Active Member
Jan 15, 2021
664
630
Except she isn't she is only doing these things for us, and doing that would piss off a lot of players, so that ain't going to happen.

Fuck I thought I was a negative person.
I think the same, as long as you follow the romantic route with her, there won't be any cheating. If the relationship is purely based on financial needs, she might follow a darker path (what might be only indicated at the end of the game).
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: TheDevian

Havik79

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2019
6,767
8,015
Or you know, we are the principal of a high school in England that le's us spank, humiliate, give girls orgasms, and will end up fucking all of them because it is this thing called a GAME.
 
4.50 star(s) 265 Votes