Joey's Conscience
Active Member
- Sep 28, 2020
- 977
- 3,024
- 408
You managed to be totally correct, while illustrating exactly what I'm saying. You know that people self-insert, yet you speak of it like something outlandish and unreasonable, when the very nature of a VN lends itself to it.If only it was possible, but let me assure you: no dev around these parts forgets the worrying degree in which some people self-insert themselves into the story and then claim entitlement over it.
The thing is, readers do not have ownership over a story. It's a relationship between an author and his audience, with the developer's role being to create and present a story on its own terms and the reader's job being to decide if that story is worth their time and interest. Constructive feedback is golden, but there is a difference in telling a developer that the elements in the story are poorly conveyed vs trying to dictate what those elements are.
Fiction beautifully offers a healthy outlet for escapism, but the moment you start worrying about being "cucked" in quantum universes, I would start thinking that I'm seeking something a porn game can't provide.
Player choice, in particular, is something that asks the reader to put himself in the shoes of the protagonist. Hell, I've seen people complain they can't name themselves in a game. Being an active participant in the story rather than a passive watcher, is something that, for many, is the only reason VNs are interesting to begin with. They feel they "own" the story, because they had input over it, even if within the confines the developer layed out.
Now I'm playing devil's advocate here. I personally don't self-insert into that many games, and I don't condone harassment of developers of any kind. I agree the dev should do as he pleases, as long as he's aware of possible implications. I've seen a couple of devs expressing regret after they added optional NTR, because they didnt antecipate the backlash they got. If the dev has a vision and they're sticking with it, that's great. But for many devs, financial sucess and having an appeased fanbase matters as much, if not more than their artistic integrity.
Last edited: