The most overrated and underrated adult games according to you.....
- Thread starter BrokenDreams
- Start date
- Apr 16, 2019
- 174
- 161
Along with the fact that the game does not justify its earning (irrespective of the quality of the game).
Welcome to open world sandbox where any sort of coherency goes out of the window to ensure the illusion of freedom.
- Aug 9, 2016
- 930
- 1,538
I've gotta chime in for the overrated aspect of Summertime Saga, though not for the content itself but for the delivery of it.
A release every 6 months usually, where the changelog is 200 lines.
"Wow, 200 lines, must be huge."
- Queue in 150 of nitty gritty details about how they changed the underlying mechanics, downright to describing how exactly the functions are coded, along with bugfixes and whatnot.
"Alright, but what about new content?"
"Ah, yeah. There's half a new scene. Enjoy."
I might be exaggerating slightly, but the premise remains the same. It absolutely does not reflect it being the top Patreon earner, having earned about $1.5m so far (ballpark figures ofc, not his accountant).
It's the full force of the avalanche effect where people join merely because tons of people are already supporting it. Or people know just about it and not other games, not sure.
As for underrated games, this is harder because there are games that I like the content but aren't supported as much as I believe they should, and others that are decently supported but don't have enough visibility. Taste is quite subjective.
Or a more objective level, I would say Pale Carnations, even though it's quite the fresh entry.
Mostly in terms of care given to the product.
There's a certain amount of polish in the UI/text/overall presentation that you rarely see in initial releases, if at all.
A release every 6 months usually, where the changelog is 200 lines.
"Wow, 200 lines, must be huge."
- Queue in 150 of nitty gritty details about how they changed the underlying mechanics, downright to describing how exactly the functions are coded, along with bugfixes and whatnot.
"Alright, but what about new content?"
"Ah, yeah. There's half a new scene. Enjoy."
I might be exaggerating slightly, but the premise remains the same. It absolutely does not reflect it being the top Patreon earner, having earned about $1.5m so far (ballpark figures ofc, not his accountant).
It's the full force of the avalanche effect where people join merely because tons of people are already supporting it. Or people know just about it and not other games, not sure.
As for underrated games, this is harder because there are games that I like the content but aren't supported as much as I believe they should, and others that are decently supported but don't have enough visibility. Taste is quite subjective.
Or a more objective level, I would say Pale Carnations, even though it's quite the fresh entry.
Mostly in terms of care given to the product.
There's a certain amount of polish in the UI/text/overall presentation that you rarely see in initial releases, if at all.
- May 9, 2018
- 1,191
- 3,680
Im not sure about the overated works.
But as underrated goes I would say Kerni 's Work he was one of the first truly 3d working producers and he did it all by himself.
https://f95zone.to/threads/abandoned-a-tale-of-forgotten-lives-kerni.187/ Was a great step for real 3d.
And
https://f95zone.to/threads/milky-ways-v0-42-beta-kerni.33000/ Looks like its going the same way.
He seems like a humble guy and a gentleman but I still think he's underated and needs some funding even if he wants it or not.
But as underrated goes I would say Kerni 's Work he was one of the first truly 3d working producers and he did it all by himself.
https://f95zone.to/threads/abandoned-a-tale-of-forgotten-lives-kerni.187/ Was a great step for real 3d.
And
https://f95zone.to/threads/milky-ways-v0-42-beta-kerni.33000/ Looks like its going the same way.
He seems like a humble guy and a gentleman but I still think he's underated and needs some funding even if he wants it or not.
Last edited:
- Sep 28, 2018
- 4,388
- 23,785
Summertime Saga and MILFY City are overrated, but they both became super popular because they are two of the first (and thus the biggest) incest games on Patreon.
Other overrated games are WVM, I like that game, but the way it blew up is a bit overboard and Foot of the Mountains. FOTM is the grindest game there ever was, I have no idea how it has such a seemingly-large fanbase. Room For Rent is like that too. Radiant too, it's a first release yet has 5k on patreon already.
As far as underrated, I think a lot of story based games are underrated. Primal Instinct for example is being abandoned, despite having great art/characters because the game never gained support.
Other overrated games are WVM, I like that game, but the way it blew up is a bit overboard and Foot of the Mountains. FOTM is the grindest game there ever was, I have no idea how it has such a seemingly-large fanbase. Room For Rent is like that too. Radiant too, it's a first release yet has 5k on patreon already.
As far as underrated, I think a lot of story based games are underrated. Primal Instinct for example is being abandoned, despite having great art/characters because the game never gained support.
Last edited:
- Apr 16, 2019
- 174
- 161
Milfy City came way after the other big incest games. I genuinely believe people love milfy city even with all the flaws. (after visiting several adult gaming website, youtube, pornhub etc).
Underrated:
https://f95zone.to/threads/dreaming-with-elsa-final-tora-productions.4961/post-192648
https://f95zone.to/threads/finding-miranda-final-tora-productions.1326/post-19378
https://f95zone.to/threads/redemption-for-jessika-final-tora-productions.202/post-1477
Overrated:
https://f95zone.to/threads/summertime-saga-v0-20-1-kompas-productions.276/post-2434
https://f95zone.to/threads/milfy-city-v0-6e-icstor.8012/post-420959
https://f95zone.to/threads/being-a-dik-v0-5-0-dr-pinkcake.25332/post-1565686
https://f95zone.to/threads/dreaming-with-elsa-final-tora-productions.4961/post-192648
https://f95zone.to/threads/finding-miranda-final-tora-productions.1326/post-19378
https://f95zone.to/threads/redemption-for-jessika-final-tora-productions.202/post-1477
Overrated:
https://f95zone.to/threads/summertime-saga-v0-20-1-kompas-productions.276/post-2434
https://f95zone.to/threads/milfy-city-v0-6e-icstor.8012/post-420959
https://f95zone.to/threads/being-a-dik-v0-5-0-dr-pinkcake.25332/post-1565686
- May 9, 2018
- 1,191
- 3,680
I think people loved the myth of Icstor, in my own opinion Milfs Control was his best game.
It's probably one of the last games he was really passionate about and it shows.
Last edited:
WVM overrated
it has a lot of content but the story is not very interesting
Primal instinct underrated
Has a good renders and the story is interesting but the fact that the family story unfolds too far slows the game
it has a lot of content but the story is not very interesting
Primal instinct underrated
Has a good renders and the story is interesting but the fact that the family story unfolds too far slows the game
- Feb 20, 2018
- 2,288
- 6,420
Overrated - a Bunch of NTR games, you literally have them averaging 3.5+ stars GTFO with that noise... look at the damn reviews, they break the first rule of reviewing of the site (keep it about the game, and more than XX number of letters)... more than 3/4 of the reviews are single line/sentence reviews like " It has NTR, so its great, 5/5 would fap again".... The main one for this is The Tyrant... its a sandbox game with no consistent progression, you could be gang chief, killed the opposition, and Nicole could still be talking about shit-face Davide in one of the repeating rooms...
Underrated - Ataegina for sure, there are a few others I could name here, but with the horrible update schedule they have I rather not, as that hurts their game for sure... Maybe Picture Perfect... and maybe Holiday Island... to a lesser extent Retrieving the Past (he's doing ok, though could be better)... Ohh almost forgot both of Neverlucky's games... Triangle despite being a cult classic and beloved never materialized into compensation for the dev, it hasnt changed with his newer work Knight's Tale.
Underrated - Ataegina for sure, there are a few others I could name here, but with the horrible update schedule they have I rather not, as that hurts their game for sure... Maybe Picture Perfect... and maybe Holiday Island... to a lesser extent Retrieving the Past (he's doing ok, though could be better)... Ohh almost forgot both of Neverlucky's games... Triangle despite being a cult classic and beloved never materialized into compensation for the dev, it hasnt changed with his newer work Knight's Tale.
- Apr 16, 2019
- 174
- 161
And you just declared war with 95% of the community
.
- Aug 22, 2018
- 26,071
- 89,953
I wasn't going to get into that one purely because some people know I have a personal dislike of the dev and I already hate one of his games, hating on both would be a bit much.
But I do think badik is garbage.
I hate the MC, I don't like the setting, I despise his friend, the love interests are all bland and the one interesting character is side content.
I hear people call it a masterpiece.
If badik is the masterpiece of adult games then Beverly Hills 90210 is the masterpiece of TV shows.
- Sep 28, 2018
- 4,388
- 23,785
3.5 stars would mean they are above average, but not good. I don't think thats fair to them, I know you personally dislike NTR, so you think all those games suck, but that doesn't mean they are overrated. A ton of incest games get 4.5 stars despite being the same as all the other incest games. Sex/fetish based games in general are overrated, people like them because of the fetish they are about, regardless of other things (story/art/characters etc).
- Aug 6, 2017
- 759
- 1,491
Most Overrated : WVM, boring as fuck, the MC is the parody of a white knight, all the females characters are empty and have the MC's dick as their only goal in life, the male characters are either assholes, boring, or useless, the plot makes no sens, this game represents everything that i hate in the adult game genre you can find in this website.
Most Underrated : Rocking Robin, this game is absolutely amazing, the story is good and thrilling, the characters are interesting with good backstory and depth, the renders are stunning, the animations are amazing, it contains all the popular kink so i really don't understand why it doesn't have more success.
Most Underrated : Rocking Robin, this game is absolutely amazing, the story is good and thrilling, the characters are interesting with good backstory and depth, the renders are stunning, the animations are amazing, it contains all the popular kink so i really don't understand why it doesn't have more success.
- Aug 9, 2016
- 930
- 1,538
I have a slight (the size of mt. Everest) hunch this is not totally based on it's actual quality.
Edit: words are hard.
Just bring it on, I am ready...........And you just declared war with 95% of the community
- Aug 6, 2017
- 759
- 1,491
Summertime Saga was one of the first, milfy city is not, icstor himself created games of this genre before it.
Without forgetting Big brother, the twist and some others.
- Feb 11, 2018
- 1,564
- 2,304
Overrated: Milfy City, Melody, Bad Memories
Underrated: Primal Instinct and Becoming a Rockstar
Underrated: Primal Instinct and Becoming a Rockstar
- Feb 17, 2018
- 405
- 5,499
Overrated? Hmm. Honestly, a lot of the games I gave high ratings to in the past I'm starting to find pretty overrated. Acting Lessons being the biggest one. I'm pretty sure I gave it 5 stars and gushed over the emotions I felt but looking back, I'm starting to feel a bit different.
Being a Dik is another one I honestly find overrated. I enjoy it a lot personally when I'm around the girls, but I don't enjoy much else about it. The comedy falls flat to me. Sometimes it's funny. BADik is why I couldn't get into American Pie, which I'm sure it's sort of derivative from, but I'm not particularly into that cliche frat shit. Every time the MC and his idiot best friend had to do something to be a Dik, I rolled my eyes. But I can't complain cause it's literally in the name of the game, so I put up with it to spend time with what actually matters to me, and that's the girls, most notably Jill, Josy, Sage and Isabella. I can also do without the free roam and the Dik/Chick score is kinda weird to me too. But DPC goes above and beyond for that game, so I genuinely respect it a lot, but I'll be honest with you fam, I skip almost all the dialogue that doesn't concern the girls. The Dik BS, the Derrick talks, some of the drug discussions. I don't care for them.
I could sit here and tell you why Milfy City, BB, AWAM, etc are all overrated, but I'd take up a page for myself.
Underrated is SUPER easy. Every game developed by Tora Productions. All of their games to me are vastly underrated. I get why people don't get into more of their games because they don't have the common dev practice of monthly updates or whatever with multiple romance options, but I feel they're really overlooked. Almost annoyingly so. I truly feel like people are missing out just because it doesn't have certain tags that they look for in games. I mean, I get it, but still.
Being a Dik is another one I honestly find overrated. I enjoy it a lot personally when I'm around the girls, but I don't enjoy much else about it. The comedy falls flat to me. Sometimes it's funny. BADik is why I couldn't get into American Pie, which I'm sure it's sort of derivative from, but I'm not particularly into that cliche frat shit. Every time the MC and his idiot best friend had to do something to be a Dik, I rolled my eyes. But I can't complain cause it's literally in the name of the game, so I put up with it to spend time with what actually matters to me, and that's the girls, most notably Jill, Josy, Sage and Isabella. I can also do without the free roam and the Dik/Chick score is kinda weird to me too. But DPC goes above and beyond for that game, so I genuinely respect it a lot, but I'll be honest with you fam, I skip almost all the dialogue that doesn't concern the girls. The Dik BS, the Derrick talks, some of the drug discussions. I don't care for them.
I could sit here and tell you why Milfy City, BB, AWAM, etc are all overrated, but I'd take up a page for myself.
Underrated is SUPER easy. Every game developed by Tora Productions. All of their games to me are vastly underrated. I get why people don't get into more of their games because they don't have the common dev practice of monthly updates or whatever with multiple romance options, but I feel they're really overlooked. Almost annoyingly so. I truly feel like people are missing out just because it doesn't have certain tags that they look for in games. I mean, I get it, but still.
- May 9, 2019
- 4,918
- 16,450
Subtle.. as the kick of a bull XDOverrated... well I'm not telling you, because I'm not being a dick! *cough* see what I did here? HaHa, but I'm joking, I haven't even played it, so I never got a perfect picture^^
Also, don't expect me to take you by the hand like a big brother, I'm not going to take you to the yellow basketball court and I'm not telling you what games I think are overrated, think for yourself
I am not here to open this can of worms. Just wanted to leave my mark in the thread, as it will be remembered as the dawn of F95's civil war.
Last edited: