xlebyshik
Newbie
- Jun 9, 2021
- 19
- 22
The issue here isn't a question of whether they can do it, but that the companies want to keep these characters going for as long as possible and letting them age gets in the way of that. Imagine if Marvel explicitly stated that an issue of Amazing Spider-Man takes place in, say, 1963 and that Spider-Man was 17 years old in this issue. If they held true to that and let the character age with each month it took for an issue to come out, then, by now, Peter Parker would be 79 years old. Anchoring a story in a specific year would eventually raise awkward questions if you're planning on having your hero still be around 20 years later in more or less the same state of being.
It's not that the application of real time is impossible in a comic book; it's just that this isn't necessarily creatively desirable. The only examples I can think of where a comic's storyline ran from month to month both IRL and in-universe is The 'Nam and Marvel's currently ongoing reboot of their Ultimate universe.
I don't get it, if they want to endlessly "exploit" the characters, then why make time frames at all? Literally, just let them not indicate the years when certain events take place so as not to confuse people and not to fool themselves with time transfers.Marvel has also tried to not tie their timelines to real world events as it gets harder and harder to keep them coherent. Simply put, the Sliding Timescale Marvel has been using isn't working anymore.
Prime example, Tony Stark (616) created the Iron Man armour when he was kidnapped during the Vietnam War. (1962, when he made his first appearance). Except, Tony Stark is supposed to be in his early 40s, meaning the Vietnam War had ended before he was born.
Likewise, the Punisher is a Vietnam veteran with multiple tours under his belt. Meaning Frank Castle should be in his 70s at least.
So to try and maintain a little coherency, Marvel brought back Sin-Cong (or Siancong), a minor Communist puppet state in Central Asia, effectively making it a stand-in for North Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan and any number of conflicts in the latter half of the 20th and 21st century, making it a location for their military based character to have their retconned origins.
Yes, it will be strange and incomprehensible, but it is better to let it be like this than some stupid movements of time lines back and forth, twisting everything so stupidly.
I don't know, maybe it looks normal for people who read comics, but for me, a person far from this, it looks more like some kind of circus with clowns and not authors who make good and thoughtful content
Last edited: