I think the problem with the Demon Vs Witch decision is that it really isn't a either or answer, but those are the only options we are being given. I whole heartedly feel that telling Lucious is the right thing to do, but it should be done with a request from his children and heir to allow 'us' to seek an alternate to the slaughter of witchs who have no idea what kind of shenanigans their queen is up to. And in doing things that way I could progress with the game without feeling like an asshole for either lying to 'my' ruler and friend, or for being responcible for so many deaths that did not need to occure (yeah, I know I spelt it wrong, but I am to lazy to look it up, but apparently not to write out all of this explaining that)
At this point, this decision ismy stopping point and it might be the end of this game for me. I don't think I can go any further without feeling guilty no matter which choice I make. (yes, I actually feel guilt for things done in games. . Yeah, i know, weird, but its the way I'm build)