Hmm, could you, please, elaborate on this? I guess Abigail has rating 30 in your game. Did you try to "get and provide her" the right dildo (I guess, you did)? What happens? Have she told you that she wants to be punished?
The notes I took while playing:
Got her up to 30 before maxing out mary to make the special event kick in.
Spied multiple times to be able to get all scenes with Simon.
After the special event, I got mary fully corrupted first.
Reading Abigail's mind is the message about her guilt for liking the way Simon treated her too much.
Trying to talk to her and try all the alternatives there.
Go to her wardrobe and can't get an option to place either of the dildo(s) in it. (nor from the wardrobe, nor the item)
2 longshots that I think might have something to do with it if all else fails:
1. I burglarized the houses early to get my sin level up fast, so I had all panties and dildoes before even talking to any of the stones.
2. I used Layla's dildo for the drone event. - Do not know if this is what causes the fuckup, but it shouldn't.
I got a few saves. one just before I started interacting with Abby all together, and one just before the special event. so I am going to give it another few tries when I got the time to play around, and see if I can replicate what happened and maybe be able to give a few more details. Or who knows maybe it was something weird that will have solved itself next time I arrive at the same spot.