Actually it's a 4,5, but the flaws are just minor in my opinion, therefore the excellent rating.
The renders are good, animations also, the cast is hot and there is enough variation in it. Even the mc looks good, which is rare in these kind of games.
Story, well nothing new, you're playing an unexperienced virgin, but good looking horse-hung guy who will have sexual relationships with the girls he meets. Gameplay is straightforward and fluent. Anyway the story is probably the weakest part of this game. I don’t say it’s badly written, I just say it’s all too obvious. But let’s be honest, you’re not here for reading, right? After all it's a porn visual novel and you want to see some action.
A minor problem is, that some boobs are looking unrealistic, though. I like it big, but more natural than displayed in this game. (Maybe the dev modelled them more after fake silicone tits, instead of big natural ones. I clearly prefer the latter and dislike silicone fake boobs.)
Furthermore some of the areolas are also located somewhat too high for such massive boobs, like the ones of the Aunt or the female Officer later on in the game. Nevertheless these really are minor issues, the women are definitively hot, especially if you like milfs. But there is also Haley, which isn’t a milf, but very much a catch, too.
Except for the Aunt and maybe Haley your later gf, the npc's won't jump at the mc's cock instantly. It requires to take the right decisions for something to happen. But it's very intuitive and not that complicated. Therefore you won't really need a walkthrough. If you want to have a certain ending, a walkthrough won't hurt. After all if you overdo and fuck everything in one play-through you might screw up your relationship with others. So there's a thin line between being bold/daring enough and fucking things up.
I really enjoyed this one and it's one of the rare completed games on this site, which is worth your time. Definitively thumbs up!