what kind of consequences personally hope it not ntr or anything like that?
- Thread starter X0R
- Start date
- Mar 6, 2020
- 1,576
- 9,744
Ok so the game is "choose one LI", by the way,it would be nice to know future tags (and no,you wouldn't be giving story spoilers if that worries you) in genre spoiler you can put the planned tags, just so the player know what to expect from the game and if he is interested or not. (for example I am not interested in lesbian and femdom and it would be good to know if there is going to have that content or not, simply with a tag you would remove the doubts, of those who are interested and those who are not)
- Sep 18, 2021
- 767
- 2,037
Like with most things, it's a give and take. A pure blank slate can be boring, but it can also give the player the freedom to decide for themselves who they want the main character to be. Meanwhile a "blank slate" that the player can shape via choices can make for a far more interesting and immersive story, but it also requires more work on the part of the dev to juggle conflicting dialogue/plot branching (ie, if you give the player the choice to decide if a specific LI is their childhood friend or childhood rival, you now have to plot out two different paths for how that character interacts with the MC).
The problem with fully fleshed out and defined MCs is the same sort of give/take - the advantage is that the dev/writer can establish deeper aspects to their history and personality that can play out as a more complex story, but the disadvantage is that they may wind up writing an MC that lots of players utterly loathe (see also the perennial complaint of many players about doormat MCs or total asshole MCs in games). In the same way, you risk having the MC feel specific ways about supporting characters that conflict with how the players do (ie, having your MC pine after an ex while most of the player base hates the ex and just wishes the MC would just get over it, or having the MC chase after a LI that most players would rather just avoid entirely).
There's also the issue of whether or not you're dealing with players who want to put themselves in the shoes of the main character versus players who just want to watch someone else's story play out. The former group will tend to like flexibility and the option to make choices and influence their version of the main character's history, backstory, personality, and relationships... while the second group will generally get more out of a deeper, more complex story they have less power over.
5 is a pretty good number for LIs. Fewer and it can feel like the player has less control/options or not enough variety, but too many more than five starts to become unwieldy to write and harder to put focus on any one individual LI (so they all start feeling underdeveloped and less interesting).
There will almost certainly be a temptation to add more as you go, either because you get new ideas, or because people promise to throw money at you on Patreon if you add [insert character stereotype here]. You'll probably be better off if you resist that urge and generally just stick to the characters you originally planned for and are putting most of your focus on. Don't let the story grow out of your control as you keep adding more and more peripheral LIs to avoid furthering the main story (way too many devs do this).
Having games where your choices matter and you can really only pursue one LI are fine. Games where you're essentially punished for trying to pursue every love interest/try for the harem route are fine. Having to choose between potential options can make for deeper stories, and the conflict between choices can make for emotional storytelling. This can be great.
But the rule of thumb you might want to keep in mind is a) you should make it very obvious early on that players are going to be expected to pick one LI and will probably get punished for being too greedy, and b) you should at least give players some leeway early to play the field a bit before drastic consequences come into play.
Become a Rock Star actually handles this pretty well - for most LIs, you can kind of flirt and even get a bit intimate with multiple girls early on, and it's really only at the point where you explicitly commit to a serious relationship that you get punished if you try and string along more than one girl. So the player has time to get to know the different LIs and decide which one they prefer before committing to one (which also helps encourage the desire to potentially play the other routes out, because the alternatives are now interesting and appealing in their own right, and not just generic ciphers you mostly ignored in favor of hyper-focusing on a single LI).
I'd recommend something similar, if possible - allow the players to have meaningful interactions with all of your LIs early on, potentially with a couple casual sex scenes each, before you reach the point where you have to pick which one to get serious about.
I'd also lightly discourage from making the consequences for choosing one girl over another too disastrous - if choosing Girl A causes Girl B to die in a fire while Girl C kills herself, even people who absolutely love Girl A may never want to choose her (and will kind of hate the game for being so cruel). Sure, there can be terrible consequences for characters (especially if the player is making bad choices), but players should never feel entirely helpless or powerless to keep most characters relatively safe and happy.
Of course. What I meant was that the MC could be in trouble the moment one of the LIs discovers that he is having fun with another girl, but it also depends on the character of the particular person. After all, not everyone reacts the same way.
- Apr 20, 2018
- 891
- 3,337
nice a doormat manlet MC with no harem, posiple ntr and femdom. Everything I'm not looking for.
good luck dev.
good luck dev.
- Apr 10, 2021
- 1,073
- 1,687
So, why give choices to the player if he always ends up having sex with the married woman? There goes the "all choices matter"...
Thank you and good luck.
Thank you and good luck.
Last edited:
- Jun 16, 2019
- 3,332
- 3,182
- May 4, 2019
- 286
- 679
I'll be keeping an eye on this one.
Dialogue has a good flow, behaviour and reactions are realistic, good looking characters and Amanda is drop dead gorgeous. Currently it looks like it's mainly a Netori game since MC starts an affair with a sexually frustrated woman married to a cheating husband but we'll see where it goes from here.
Choices are kind of simple, it's either bad/lusty or good/responsible.
No animations but the sex scene was quite good.
Dialogue has a good flow, behaviour and reactions are realistic, good looking characters and Amanda is drop dead gorgeous. Currently it looks like it's mainly a Netori game since MC starts an affair with a sexually frustrated woman married to a cheating husband but we'll see where it goes from here.
Choices are kind of simple, it's either bad/lusty or good/responsible.
No animations but the sex scene was quite good.
- Jun 10, 2017
- 496
- 639
Good luck for your game.. Renders looks good.. For me also which is important future tags.. Do you think put cheating , cuckold or lesbian routes ?
- Sep 2, 2018
- 814
- 2,550
Actually something went wrong. All this chatter about the importance of choices and there's no way to say "fuck off" to the cheating whore. No matter what you do, you have to bang her.
- Aug 20, 2018
- 680
- 2,495
It's looks ok so far ,renders are decent models are nice tough .someone already mentioned the lack of choices on sexual preference and dev's notes says every choice will have consequence, that creates two problems it will absolutely required a Walkthrough and lots of different choices means lots of work for dev so longer gaps between each update.
. Second Let's say you have 5 lis so content will be distributed between them and since it's not a harem game (dev said they will cut mc into pieces as a consequence lol) you will only get 20% of the content at one go and I don't think many here replay a vn 5 times to get all the contents unless it's very High quality and story rich .
even if you do a 400 ,500 renders release the player will get very little content wise since one Li only .so unless dev can make 1000 renders each update give every route a decent amount of play time I don't know how it will work .
Animation not a big deal for me but point and click tag I am a bit worried about because I have seen a lot of bad implementation of that in the past .
And yeah pls add future tags as it's help players to decide if they want to play or not .and saves a lot of unnecessary toxic fights in the comments.
. Second Let's say you have 5 lis so content will be distributed between them and since it's not a harem game (dev said they will cut mc into pieces as a consequence lol) you will only get 20% of the content at one go and I don't think many here replay a vn 5 times to get all the contents unless it's very High quality and story rich .
even if you do a 400 ,500 renders release the player will get very little content wise since one Li only .so unless dev can make 1000 renders each update give every route a decent amount of play time I don't know how it will work .
Animation not a big deal for me but point and click tag I am a bit worried about because I have seen a lot of bad implementation of that in the past .
And yeah pls add future tags as it's help players to decide if they want to play or not .and saves a lot of unnecessary toxic fights in the comments.
Last edited:
- Aug 20, 2018
- 680
- 2,495
Heh I didn't knew it was not a harem game ,I played untill they split the route then stopped after that good game till that point though,so yeah you are right it should be atleast mentioned on the start of the game that it's a single Li game .
- Apr 10, 2021
- 1,073
- 1,687
And don't waste people's time.
Nope.
They haven't appeared yet.
I will paste you the text from my 2nd message on the patron page.
I started working on the game from EP 1.That is why I have the MC and LIs already created.
The plan was that during the interaction MC with the world, I would throw in pieces from his past — events of a few/some weeks ago to show what happened to the MC.
Later, I decided that I was not experienced enough as a creator to mix the present with the past and chose to start from the beginning — in this case, with the creation of EP 0.
That is why the MC has only one choice regarding Amanda. This is how it looks in my script. It had to happen, so I just enriched it with a few choices in which you can earn points with Amanda and slowly begin to shape the character of the MC. For sure, the situation will change with the release of Ep1.
If some of you don't like it, so be it.
Also, it was good practice for me to branch out the story, not only in terms of coherency but also how much more work it requires.
Last edited: