Perhaps the problem doesn't reside within the many others, but rather that you have played so many games that you have become desensitized to the simple novelty of the adult video game experience?
There is nothing new under the sun - and just like movies, tv shows, novels, general video games - hundreds, thousands are churned out every year with similar storylines, concepts, etc but only very few become popular and fewer become critically acclaimed. Even fewer turn tropes on end or subvert expectations. However, most people don't attempt to see them all, read the all, etc --- but it seems there is a trend on F95 in attempting to play them all. When people do attempt to see/read all movies, tv shows, novels, etc -- similar complaints are made in those areas of entertainment as well.
Also, it is good to remember that most of the developers of the adult video games found on F95 are not full-time creators -- this is their hobby, second job, activity outside of education, a way to expand/build/develop their skills in coding/writing/art, or building their portfolio for later works.
Best advice.