VN Ren'Py Where the Heart Is [S1 Rev1] [CheekyGimp]

4.30 star(s) 336 Votes
Discussion Reviews (336)
Ariostebaldo

Ariostebaldo

Active Member
Sep 17, 2020
843
1,309
voyeurkind said:
To me, I don't think you can romance Debbie without including Lily. Debbie is in love with Lily--not just like, not just want to get in her pants, but love--and has been for some time now. I think any activity by the MC to get in the way of that will ultimately lead to a bad ending even if you do convince her to be yours.

In other words, in my opinion, if you're going for Debbie, you need to at minimum stay out of her way when she confesses to Lily.
Click to expand...
I see it otherwise. Have you never tried to convince someone that was in love with other someone that you were the right person? Of course the MC should respect Debby if she were already dating, but even if she is in love with Lily, she isn't even dating her. It is pitiful to keep pushing after someone who will never want you, hypothetically speaking... but I'm almost sure Debby said MC was one of the two people she loved, so looking from MC perspective, all he needed was that things with Lily didn't go well for Debby.

Again, I know that the right choices to succeed in geting Debby as LI is saying you want Debby for yourself, accept to help her with Lily (which would be pretty dumb in real life), and then leting she experience with Lily... but I'm just talking hyphotetically here, what could hyphotetically happen.

ename144 said:
In theory this is supposed to be one of those 'Beauty and the Beast' moments where the MC realizes that if he really cares about Debbie he can't deny her the chance to be happy with someone else. So he stands aside. Debbie, in turn, realizes her love for Lily was illusory and the MC is the real thing. A little trite, perhaps, but well within the tone of the game and quite satisfying.

In practice, though, it runs into some problems. The MC and Debbie really needed to have a serious heart to heart before Debbie starts her seduction run; the quick conversation in the bedroom is way too short and barely touches on the main topic. As a result, what should be an act of selflessness instead feels like Debbie ignoring the MC and/or the MC overreacting after being too slow in bring up his concerns. Not quite as romantic.

Sadly, I think the game was too focused on making sure everyone got to the hot orgy and thus didn't devote the time needed to properly lead up to the moment from all the various possible routes. One can certainly argue that was a prudent use of limited resources, as I think genuinely solo Lily/Debbie routes are a small minority. But I feel like there could have been a better balancing point without significantly more cost if they had focused on the relationships first and the sex second.

Still, this is what we have. IMHO it at least addresses the major concerns in some way, so I'm quite willing to roll with it.
Click to expand...
I agree with you. And I'm not saying the story is not well told, it's actually pretty good. I'm just looking from another point of view.
 
Avaron1974

Avaron1974

Resident Lesbian
Aug 22, 2018
26,090
90,045
Ariostebaldo said:
Well, I made a save for each girl even for the ones I don't like, such as Zarah, Jolina, Katie, etc. Debby ain't my least favorite, but it feels like she's trying to use the MC as ladder to get what she wants. I agree the MC shouldn't try to change Debby mind, but since I'm trying to romance all girls in separate saves, I made one for Debby too. I'm not complaining, I'm just saying...
Click to expand...
She isn't using him, she genuinely picks him afterwards but she's been trying to get out that has feelings for her for a long time now and that kiss needed to happen to get it out of her system.

There is nothing for the Mc to be jealous of, Deb knows she's going to be with him she just needed that moment.
 
  • Angry
  • Like
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Avaron1974 still a CUNT, Call the POLICE:))))))))), Avaron sucks my DICK and 15 others
wizardcock

wizardcock

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2021
1,230
3,424
Great game. Didn't think I would feel like a bastard, but after "Sorry sir. Did you order a goddess?" everything changed. So my heart is where Katie is. But that doesn't change where the other part of my body was. Hopefully the endings will be realistic and the "bad" guys like me will get what they deserve. It would be interesting emotions.
 
Crippy

Crippy

Active Member
May 28, 2018
975
527
Ilhares said:
Man, are you telling me I have to wait until I'm 13? This is unbearable.
Click to expand...
I have a younger brother in the same boat. But, it is better than the next release date of Feb 30. I have pulled that a few times with favorable success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ilhares
felicemastronzo

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,796
22,761
ename144 said:
In theory this is supposed to be one of those 'Beauty and the Beast' moments where the MC realizes that if he really cares about Debbie he can't deny her the chance to be happy with someone else. So he stands aside. Debbie, in turn, realizes her love for Lily was illusory and the MC is the real thing. A little trite, perhaps, but well within the tone of the game and quite satisfying.

In practice, though, it runs into some problems. The MC and Debbie really needed to have a serious heart to heart before Debbie starts her seduction run; the quick conversation in the bedroom is way too short and barely touches on the main topic. As a result, what should be an act of selflessness instead feels like Debbie ignoring the MC and/or the MC overreacting after being too slow in bring up his concerns. Not quite as romantic.

Sadly, I think the game was too focused on making sure everyone got to the hot orgy and thus didn't devote the time needed to properly lead up to the moment from all the various possible routes. One can certainly argue that was a prudent use of limited resources, as I think genuinely solo Lily/Debbie routes are a small minority. But I feel like there could have been a better balancing point without significantly more cost if they had focused on the relationships first and the sex second.

Still, this is what we have. IMHO it at least addresses the major concerns in some way, so I'm quite willing to roll with it.
Click to expand...
unfortunately in these games there is always the problem of reduced time, the characters must come to terms with their feelings in a very short time (for me the least likely situation remains MC who forgives Elaine the first time he sees her, after having always spoken ill of her)

however a moment of dialogue with Debbie is there, it can be rushed but a minimum of confrontation is allowed.

in the whole scene what doesn't add up for me is that MC is essentially given two options: stay and participate in the revelry, or run away.
the only alternative he has is escape and this is proposed to him over and over again, Debbie wants to talk to him? and he can run away. the girls kiss? and he can run away. the girls want him to undress? and he can run away

and this choice, especially before the 3-4some if they are interested in Lily or Debbie, in my opinion, is quite strange.
let me explain better, mc agrees to help Debbie to declare herself to Lily, she does it, things go more or less well for her, and at that point what does mc do? he publicly declares his love to one of the two. it seems to me a rather abrupt move. if you are interested in Debbie you are putting her in a very tight spot at the moment when she has finally found the courage to declare herself to Lily, and in the same way if you declare yourself to Lily, in fact you are completely blocking the way to Debbie, at that point what have you helped her to do?

Translated with
You must be registered to see the links
(free version)
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrFriendly, ename144 and whichone
whichone

whichone

Forum Fanatic
Jan 3, 2018
4,915
10,324
felicemastronzo said:
and this choice, especially before the 3-4some if they are interested in Lily or Debbie, in my opinion, is quite strange.
let me explain better, mc agrees to help Debbie to declare herself to Lily, she does it, things go more or less well for her, and at that point what does mc do? he publicly declares his love to one of the two. it seems to me a rather abrupt move. if you are interested in Debbie you are putting her in a very tight spot at the moment when she has finally found the courage to declare herself to Lily, and in the same way if you declare yourself to Lily, in fact you are completely blocking the way to Debbie, at that point what have you helped her to do?
Click to expand...
Well said. (y) Ben detto
 
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: Subyan, Avaron1974 still a CUNT, Bane71 still a BITCH and 9 others
Raptus Puellae

Raptus Puellae

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2020
1,643
2,281
felicemastronzo said:
unfortunately in these games there is always the problem of reduced time, the characters must come to terms with their feelings in a very short time (for me the least likely situation remains MC who forgives Elaine the first time he sees her, after having always spoken ill of her)

however a moment of dialogue with Debbie is there, it can be rushed but a minimum of confrontation is allowed.

in the whole scene what doesn't add up for me is that MC is essentially given two options: stay and participate in the revelry, or run away.
the only alternative he has is escape and this is proposed to him over and over again, Debbie wants to talk to him? and he can run away. the girls kiss? and he can run away. the girls want him to undress? and he can run away

and this choice, especially before the 3-4some if they are interested in Lily or Debbie, in my opinion, is quite strange.
let me explain better, mc agrees to help Debbie to declare herself to Lily, she does it, things go more or less well for her, and at that point what does mc do? he publicly declares his love to one of the two. it seems to me a rather abrupt move. if you are interested in Debbie you are putting her in a very tight spot at the moment when she has finally found the courage to declare herself to Lily, and in the same way if you declare yourself to Lily, in fact you are completely blocking the way to Debbie, at that point what have you helped her to do?

Translated with
You must be registered to see the links
(free version)
Click to expand...
I am on the harem path so there was always Katie to consider
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.30 star(s) 336 Votes