Since it's trendy to rank the ladies in this game, here is my order and details.
#1 - Katie. All of what i said about here before is still valid. She is also the one who loves and cares about the MC the most. I can't find the words to explain it properly, but throughout the gameplay her feelings became much much deeper than any of the other characters in the game. Certainly if i met her irl i'd marry her in a heartbeat.
#2 - Bella. There is something really fishy about her behavior, but at the same time, she is sooo entrancing. The wild nature inside her along with the gorgeous looks and the charisma around her. I really hope she won't end up trying to screw over the MC. Could be a loyal partner if all the things she says are true.
#3 - Jolina. Bimbo with a desire to proof to the world she is more than just a set of gorgeous tits, ass, legs and face; that there is some brain behind that pretty face. Although this isn't anything new to the world, i kinda like it and the way she does it. Granted she also acts really suspicious and gives the GoldDigger vibes and might have another motives behind all of her actions, but she is still gorgeous, matured and somewhat grounded until this point.
#4 - Monica, Jenna and Lily. All 3 of them are at the same level of appeal to me and at this point it's not what pulls me towards the character, but what repulses me. Monica is constantly afraid of other people's opinion if they found out about her and the MC. Jenna is in constant need of reassurance and motivation and this really drives me crazy at times. Lily is so shallow that even her body can't make up for it. All she cares about is looks. Even her hobby, designing clothes is about making her appear more attractive to the rest of the world.
#5 - Debbie. She is kinda neither here or there. She is the type of girl you would call just to have some fun and she will gladly answer and in the end both of you would know it's just for fun. Everything is purely physical and nothing else in common. You know... she is not your type, you are not her type, but both of you would fuck each other if there is no one else around.
#6 - Wanda. Here is a shocker - the wannabe model bitch before the rest of the remaining. When you talk to her you get the sense she's been treated like a garbage her entire life. She simply didn't have any proper examples to follow. Maybe i'm a bi optimistic, but i think that with the proper attitude and help, she could be turned into a descent human being and maybe even a good partner.
#7 - Theresa. yup the religious nutjob seems like a really fun ride. Certainly not for anything serious and should be handled with care (have to keep a constant line of sight with her hands), but i bet a real sexual monster is just waiting to show up. I like this sort of milfs.
#8 - Zarah. She is just the typical meneater. She is just around to fuck whoever she likes w/o getting into any sort of complications. She might say she has some feelings and so on and even if this is true, those same feeling would disappear the moment she finds a new target. She is the one you'd call if you want some fun, w/o obligations and Debbie is occupied.
#9 - Elaine. The bitch playing saint. For me 90% of her actions are a play and it's all a part of her game, but why not have some fun, while trying to outplay her.
#10 - Angel. Although she might turn to be the 3rd party, she is completely indifferent to me. She can't offer anything i'd be interested in.
As for Natasha, can't really see her as any form of potential interest. She is just waaaay too spoilt to appeal even solely to my boner. If you ever wonder what a hatefuck is, she is the perfect description.