My own choices... I had to replay parts of the game to put names to faces as it's been a while, so I edited your image and put names on the faces. I'll also attach my Photoshop file for this, each image is a separate layer so anyone else can drag these around and make their own, just for fun.
View attachment 1924499
View attachment 1924500
Heres My Own List. Better characters go further left.
15: Porsche. Too small a role to matter to me
14: Also a relatively small role. Sexy but is just temptation.
13: A fun character but severely held back by how bad she looks. She looks old and haggard. The new haircut was nice tho.
12:Good sex scenes but her face seriously creeps me out. Its something about her nose. I just don't feel attracted to her.
11:OK so heres were we get the saucy stuff. A lot of y'all seem to really like Katie, which I can't really understand. I find her 'banter' gets repetitive and cringey really quickly. Every conversation with her follows the same pattern:
Katie: "Hey bro, I'm a fucking queen"
PC: "Dirty Joke Haha"
Katie: Oh my god, you're not fucking serious haha. Man I'm such a fucking jealous person, did I tell you I'm a fucking jealous person?"
PC: "Jealousy joke haha"
Katie: Oh my god, you're not fucking serious haha. I fucking love you. Fucking bye."
Rinse, repeat for 20 episodes. Now, I am exaggerating. There is development with her and things change. But the long bouts of Joke Response Joke Response never cease. The 2nd point against Katie is that her looks seem to suddenly downgrade a few episodes in. The first few episodes, she looks really hot, with lovely skin and a pretty face. Then suddenly, her skin gets a lot of red hues, like sunburns, and her face seems to change a little. Or maybe it's her new hairstyle. Whatever it is, she just suddenly becomes really unattractive to me.
10. OK So Jenna is interesting in that she's the opposite of Katie. She starts off unattractive then becomes pretty banging. The issue for me is just how BAD she did look in the beginning. Her skin was
literally grey. For a long time, I really did not feel any attraction for her, and that sort of dampened her eventual glow up for me. Her personality isn't as annoying as Katies, but she takes special liberties with your privacy which is kinda annoying. Overall, I she's not bad objectively, I just don't like her.
9. Angel is completely average in every way.
8. Natasha is quite hot and her scenes are SPICY.
7. Jolina is the one I feel I should be most attracted to, but for some reason I'm not. Maybe I've just seen her 'look' too often in these kinds of games. Fairly fun sex scenes and personality tho. She ain't bad. She just isn't great either.
6. Theresa excites the kink side of me. Her personality is super fun to interact with and contributes to great tension in her sex scenes. She also looks really cool in a different way than you normally see.
5. Wanda starts off bad but gets really good. She's quite cute looking- it's just her attitude that's ugly. At least, it is until the game puts you into a sado-maso dynamic with her, and suddenly all her scenes are super hot with great tension. Just a lot of fun with her.
4. Elaine really grew with me over time. I'm still not sure what her full deal is, but sexual scenes with her are always super hot because they truly feel authentic and taboo. Getting her wet in the garage, Flirting with her, easing into a relationship with this woman who was a complete bitch to you before... it's a very satisfying route. Also she's is beautiful yet looks 'real'. Great design.
3. I don't know why so many of y'all don't appreciate Monica, she is 1. Fine as hell and 2. Full of scenes rife with sexual tension. To expand on these points, Monica is a hot ass Milf with lovely skin and actually alluring face. She really looks like she could be a MILF. Only drawbacks to her design is that she leans into the typical over sized breasts and ass that these MILF characters always have. But it's not so much that it takes me out of the scenes. And her scenes are great. From the get go, every scene with Monica is full of Taboo tension and desire. It's a great payoff when things finally do happen.
2. Lily is the hottest character IMO, and she's got a fun personality. All round, she's just really great.
1. On first glance, Debbie just looks like a normal girl with an average body. But then she starts flirting with you, and things happen and you see what she can do. And honestly, Debbie is just the absolute sexiest character in this game. Every scene with her is super hot. The things she does and the way she acts is unbelievably alluring. And she's just got a genuinely fun, friendly and flirty personality to boot. The fact that her body has realistic proportions also helps amplify her hotness I think. She deserves her spot as my Number 1.