I'm late to the party but here is my favorite girls list:
1 - Elaine: Love her looks and I always like these "redeeming character" stories, trying to fix mistakes from the past, my favorite character for sure.
2 - Katie: Best main girl in my opinion, looks great with both hairstyles and I love her personality and the banter, wouldn't want her to change the way she is at all.
3 - Bella: There may be something weird with her but damn she looks good and the scenes with her are the best.
4 - Jolina: I still think she may be hiding something, but that body, to me she is one of the hottest girls in the game and she is always fun.
5 - Lily: Love that personality of hers, she is so fun and looks great too. Wouldn't want to share her with Debby though... I know it's weird but I'm usually not into that.
I think that would be it, bonus for Wanda, didn't get into the list but is one of my favorites too!