I must be one of those oddball minorities.
I can't stand that game.
Sorry if this will sound offensive or anything, since it's not meant as such, but I really can't help not being an obnoxious smartass for a minute. I think you'd probably enjoy that game more if the I in its title would be replaced by Y though.
Joke aside, roleplaying as a hormone fueled college dickhead probably really has something to do with you disliking that game.
As for the new update of the WTHI, it indeed confirmed my fear that being a manslut won't end well, though it wasn't really a big surprise to be honest. I agree that the harem ending wouldn't really fit well into this game but I suppose I still kept a sliver of hope that we'll be able to pull it off with polyamorous relationships due to the hints of threesomes earlier in the game.
Katie will always be a first choice for me, but while I had no problem breaking the relationships with women that didn't particularly interest me in the first place (like Monica, Elaine, Zarah and Angel), I found myself not being able to break off with Jenna. Hell, breaking off with her after we coaxed her out of her shell seemed to me like throwing a puppy into a wood chipper after you adopted him from the dog pound just because you realized your cat doesn't like him. I also found out I have trouble breaking it off with Jo, mainly due to her character if less so due to her looks. And then there is Wanda, of course. Sigh, I really hope I will be able to convince Katie to adopt her as our subby pet slut but I wouldn't really bet on my chances there. As for Bella, Lilly and Debbie I am somehow ambivalent. Lilly was hot as hell in this last update and her hidden depths seem intriguing but since I usually don't go for bimbo types I suppose I could find the will to end that particular relationship.
So I guess I'd be happy with Katie and Jenna in the end, with Jo as a occasional partner and Wanda as a subby pet but yeah, I think there's snowball's chance in hell for that. Oh well, I guess I'll try to pull it off and see what Katie does to me when I try to talk her into it. Some things are worth dying for painfully.