With a New Game+, this is one of those games that are intended to be played multiple times. But honestly, you need tons of art assets to make that worthwhile. I've unlocked all the art in a single playthrough and yeah, I'm not going to NG+.
Story 3/10
Honestly? I didn't get to see all of it (or much of it at all). I only played through once. I can see that there's a story back there, but I have no idea how to unlock it. This is one of those games where it's basically impossible to progress without a walkthrough (one of the steps to progress a quest is to eat at a particular inn at a particular town). And I followed the walkthrough and I'm still lost. Like, a lot of things are locked, apparently, because I did things out of order.
...
But how was I supposed to know that? Even now, I have no idea what the order is supposed to be.
I rag on hallway simulators all the time but at least you can't fuck it up.
Gameplay 6/10
The gameplay is basically top down hack and slash on procedurally generated maps. You can swing your sword, cast ranged magic, sprint, and chug a health pot. The game play is very simple. But it's surprisingly entertaining as well.
Sadly, it's also one of those lose-to-scene games. So I found myself purposefully losing to see if I get a new scene (most of the times I didn't get a new scene). So it's a big time sink.
On the procedurally generated maps, I think the game needed a compass. Remember how I said you need to do really specific things to progress quests? One of those is getting to end of dungeons. And I can't tell if the next trigger is at the end of a dungeon I've already beaten. So just gotta run through it. Again and again and again. But it's procedurally generated maps so I spent a ton of time running through low level maps just to see if one of my quests would progress.
Lastly, the game is kind of grindy. Sometimes I'd just sit there and tank hits while chugging potions to grind up my def stat.
Art 7/10
The art isn't amazing, but it's not bad. The girl is cute and the scenes are hot. There are a variety of positions that an encounter can take and you get exp for the various things that happen.
AFAICT sex exp does absolutely bupkis save for desire for sex, which increases your estrus. The girl doesn't become more corrupt or anything. It's just numbers and tracking. There's no observable difference. As you can tell, I'm very disappointed (and if there were effects, it was so minor I didn't notice it).
The girl can also be customized with a bunch of clothes that you can purchase. And there's quite a lot of clothes.
The one drawback on the art is the low number of scenes. If you take into account positions, then there's a large variety of scenes. But the number of scenes is like... 30? 20?
Overall 5/10
I do like games with the girl always standing on the side. Honestly, she got in the way of gameplay. But you know what? This is an h-game and I want the h in the game.
However, the low number of scenes and the way the story got broken due to player actions is lame. Personally, I think all content should always be achievable. No failure states. Because really, I already spent 10 hours to get to this point. I do not want to spend another 10 on a NG+ because I did shit out of order.