Having look it over... I gotta say it kinda feels half-assed.
Like, in nearly every regard.
It has the grounds for an amazing game. But... it has no direction. (It has started to get one in the later builds.)
Again: A game that is kinda so shit, that the only "real" version to play is to cheat is kinda... failed at the starting line.
Another weak point to me is their genitalia. Like... he made the PC the standard "utterly useless at sex, but with a big dick!" dude. Who ironically has more effort and detail put into his dick, than ALL of the girls combined. They're literally just copy pasted clones. If I can print screen every scene in the game and show the pussy. And no-one here can tell who the fuck that character is... I'd say you need SOME more work there.
I know it's common to make every girl a loli, and every guy a big dick/hyper pornstar.
But it just makes it extra irrelevant what character you go for. They're all just the same in dialogue, appearance and porn scenes.
It is imo good he dumped the romance scenes. (As said: It's starting to get a focus. And tbh: How the FUCK do you go a romance route with a homicidal, sadistic rapist? xD)
I mean, as mentioned quite a few times: He's bland. Has less charm than a wet blanket. It utterly incompetent at sex. And all the girls are dumb as fucking bricks for any of his schemes to work plot con wise. Like... they don't notice ANYTHING really. It's like things happen in a vacuum. And no character even communicates. One moment in particular is VERY "you crossed the fucking line!" and... nothing. They just derp and stare at the wall. It's something that'd pretty much warrent the PC getting murdered and/or raped to death. Or his dick bitten off. But nope. No consequences. The girls fight back with the power of an empty potato sack. (There's a ton of hoops being jumped to justify stuff here)
I can get people wanting to play Gary Stu's in rape games, where they play god mod and be as stupid as they want, with no chance of failing. And while subjective: I like being able to take risks in games like this. Kinda classic high risk, high reward. Or be prepared for backlash if I do reckless shit. But this is kinda the equivalent of starting up an RPG, putting no points into your primary stat, spending everything in your dump stat, getting naked and running to the end game zone and... beating every enemy with one punch, just winning. I don't want to speculate but... I have some suspicions about the creator.
With a proper writer, and some overhauls, I think this could be a lot more than just... "just another plot con rape game with a Gary Stu". The graphics are really good... half the time. Somethings just look really out of place. Like, if I'm being honest: Hay Lin. She is just kinda full uncanny valley.
I do feel bad the creator has wasted a ton of time on this. (In terms of the reworks so far.)
I think he started with a too big aim. He wanted to do ALL the things. And then kinda, halfway through stating realized that he in fact: could not do all the things. And the game is now more about salvaging what he can to cobble together something functional. Part of why work-shopping and feedback is so vital imo.
I mean, in my experience going in: It kinda went from "Oh, neat. A WITCH parody porn game." to "Oh... a self-insert OC game that stole the appearances of a franchise." I mean: I almost expected all characters names to be a letter or two off from their original ones.
I still rate this game above those with shit tagging.
... I mean, the overview of this game is pretty dang poor. But you at least get some idea via the tags.
But it's at least not one of those games that doesn't contain several of the tags, or turns out that you were "actually playing as a dude all along! You just pretended to be a chick!" or some bs.
I'd say it's a "solid let down". As it's a solid game for those that want a Gary Stu rape simulator.
But lets anyone down that wants a WITCH game.
Along with needing polish on the models, gameplay and a slew of other areas.