It's true, I agree with you.He mostly seem to lack direction and focus.
Kinda "This would be cool" without checking if it works with the characters and settings.
Like, not the best examples but: "I like Farmville, I'm gonna add a farming section." and "I light Star Wars, I'm gonna add a lightsaber duel!" and "I'm gonna make this guy evil for no reason so I can have some hyper anal sex!"
So, we're left with stuff that would make for good, 4 different games.
Like: An inter-dimensional brothel is a cool game idea. A rape game is a simple game idea. A blackmail game is a simple idea. (that could work with a rape game. but requires slight effort) A "redemption grinding dating sim" is a classic idea. He just tries to make it ALL the games+genres at once.
I think that the game and the story are lost a lot when we put everything in a mixer, then it is even very difficult to "fix" or "fix" to improve the story and become more coherent.