There's over 5100 games on this site at the moment and based on overall likes and a weighted review average this game is in the top 40 of both of those categories so obviously there are a whole bunch of people who do like it for a variety of reasons.
Some people enjoy the way the dialogue, gameplay, overall direction, theme, and story of the game is going. It's fine if you don't enjoy it and we're all entitled to opinions here but if you feel that way, might I'd advise to put that in a review?
Otherwise it kind of sounds like you're coming off a little condescending and inviting a pointless back and forth with people that's only going to lead to stupid arguments over why someone should or shouldn't like the game..
Well, I'm not here to argue about what or why everyone likes a game. I understand 100% that different people like different games. In fact, not being an NTR fan myself, I strongly dislike repeated shooting down of NTR game by people not liking NTR games in the NTR game threads. It's all a bit pointless.
I'm genuinely surprised about the games popularity and feel like I'm missing something. Before starting a game, I like the game to be at least 6 months to a year old. If a game is less then a year old, I do look at the rating, before starting a game. I have rarely found a 4+ star game, seemingly in a genre that I typically enjoy (Which is most genres, except extreme corruption, rape, blackmail, NTR etc.), that are not exceptionally good.
This game is definitely not bad, but I feel that I'm missing something that everyone else sees that's making this game so good.
I'm not condescending to anyone liking the game, definitely to each their own, but yes I would like some opinions on my view instead of just a like in the ratings (You can not dislike a rating).
TLDR, Normally, if the game is in a genre I enjoy, the rating/likes is a pretty good indicator for me if I would enjoy it as well.
In this instance, I'm not feeling it and I'm wondering if I'm approaching the game wrong (maybe my expectations were too high), or if there are other people enjoying the game but have similar criticisms then me.