Opinions are obviously allowed here when talking about the game and subject matter - just don't be surprised when people don't necessarily agree with your opinion. Are the facepalms a bit much? Probably, but just like you in a way they're expressing their opinions as well.
With regards to the point you were making --- Some people enjoy the dialogue / some don't. Personally I like it that the MC's dialogue is measured and mature in a way.
He comes across as someone who isn't a complete idiot, chauvinistic, or someone who thinks they're God's gift to women which is nice because someone of his position (a highly coveted basketball recruit at first - later the star player on a below average or poor team) could easily adapt a God complex of sorts and act on his carnal impulses, feel entitled, and be the biggest alpha douches of douches.
Maybe it's not portrayed to those outside of America (or to those who don't follow sports closely) that well but the way colleges treat prized recruits in sports like basketball and american football is very accurate to a degree as it is in this game (personally I played baseball at a DI school in college some years ago and lived in a dorm my first 2 years on campus that housed the football and basketball teams as well. I saw up close how administrators, professors, coaches, etc looked the other way on a lot of things those guys did. I remember a guy who now plays in the NFL basically having orgies on a weekly basis with some of his teammates and girls in his dorm room, noise complaints that were never enforced, the guy had an Aston Martin that was "loaned" to him by a booster, shit was insane).
Point being, it is a little realistic in a way that the girls and people in general to an extent treat a star athlete like a semigod because frankly, that's how a lot of star athletes are treated on college campuses. Especially athletes in basketball and football since they bring in millions for a school (
You must be registered to see the links
)