VN Ren'Py Yesterday's Crossroads [Ch.3 v0.4.1a] [CHAQUINN0]

[Raziel_8]

Just finished the game and here's how i would rate the girls.

S TIER: Olivia - Basically drama free, may take a turn for the worse depending on how she handles her fathers death.
A TIER: Michelle and Alessa (without vera) - both are fantastic and sucks you cant throuple both sisters.
B TIER: Kimberly, Julia and Candice - Fine choices just a bit boring.
C Tier: Alyssa + Vera (pretty much a sub/dom relationship that i have no interest in)

F TIER: Kim and Keyla - you reap what you sow.

Keyla is actually the hottest girl in the game but boy she is such a trash ass character.

For me it would be

S-Tier :
-Michelle, just can't say no to her or make her sad
A-Tier :
-Olivia, no much drama, likeable all around and one of the best looking girls
-Julia, only downside is that it feels really rushed (thought i think the dev said he will rework some of early parts). Also i really don't want to get involved in that drama with the ex...i hope it is dealt with swift.
B-Tier:
-Kimmy, her chemistry with the MC is great and she is fun, thought, not really my type.
-Vera without Alessa, hot and fun (and yeah, i know not gonna happen)
C-Tier:
- Alessa, dunno i just don't find anything particular interesting about her, even the backstory is just kinda bland
- Candace, same as Alessa, i just don't find her interesting, feels overal more like a sidegirl
F-Tier:
-Alessa+Vera, frankly just no interest in a poly relation. Maybe it would have worked for me if they wouldn't be a couple, the throuple being formed later on and they wouldn't be bi.
-Kim, i so hope we can bang her sister and make sure she will know
-Keyla, everything about the backstory and her relation with Zecke is bringing her down hard and make her look really stupid. If she would at least fight to get the MC now, but even that she doesn't do, just sitting on her ass, waiting and doing nothing.

 

[MagicMan753]

Haven't played in a couple chapters, and I planned to when dev did slight rework, got lost with other VNs and other stuff, then planned to come back for ch.4, but reading some of this about Keyla has me worried. She isn't my favorite but I actually like her a lot, and was hoping she got some good stuff, but from sounds of it, she got shafted a bit.

Feels like this always happens to girls I really like, they just get treated like less and like they don't matter by devs most of time where they show favoritism to others.
So now I am sad, cause she was one of the girl's paths(A few in front of her) I was excited to play when I jumped back in, but now I feel let down, with her apparently not even showing interest in us or fight for us.

 

[MiltonPowers]

Just finished the game and here's how i would rate the girls.

S TIER: Olivia - Basically drama free, may take a turn for the worse depending on how she handles her fathers death.
A TIER: Michelle and Alessa (without vera) - both are fantastic and sucks you cant throuple both sisters.
B TIER: Kimberly, Julia and Candice - Fine choices just a bit boring.
C Tier: Alyssa + Vera (pretty much a sub/dom relationship that i have no interest in)

F TIER: Kim and Keyla - you reap what you sow.

Keyla is actually the hottest girl in the game but boy she is such a trash ass character.

S - Michelle
A - Riley
B - Candace

Alyssa & Kimberly - S-Tier sister-in-laws.

the rest.

Z - Kim & Keyla

 

[Malicre]

To be fair in my tier list the only girls i actively dislike are Alyssa + Vera (together), Kim and Keyla and it seems like that is the general consensus looking at most peoples tier list.

If i could have both the sisters that would def be S+ tier but the story isnt set up to allow that and i don't want to pick one over the other.

 

[Zorro#34]

Haven't played in a couple chapters, and I planned to when dev did slight rework, got lost with other VNs and other stuff, then planned to come back for ch.4, but reading some of this about Keyla has me worried. She isn't my favorite but I actually like her a lot, and was hoping she got some good stuff, but from sounds of it, she got shafted a bit.

Feels like this always happens to girls I really like, they just get treated like less and like they don't matter by devs most of time where they show favoritism to others.
So now I am sad, cause she was one of the girl's paths(A few in front of her) I was excited to play when I jumped back in, but now I feel let down, with her apparently not even showing interest in us or fight for us.

I haven't played the rework either, merely planning to when Ch. 4 releases, so I'm no better informed than you. Considering that the guys who are agree on Keyla, however…
Also, I certainly remember Keyla being interested in the MC. It's just that he didn't feel as sharing the sentiment to me.

 

[Malicre]

Haven't played in a couple chapters, and I planned to when dev did slight rework, got lost with other VNs and other stuff, then planned to come back for ch.4, but reading some of this about Keyla has me worried. She isn't my favorite but I actually like her a lot, and was hoping she got some good stuff, but from sounds of it, she got shafted a bit.

Feels like this always happens to girls I really like, they just get treated like less and like they don't matter by devs most of time where they show favoritism to others.
So now I am sad, cause she was one of the girl's paths(A few in front of her) I was excited to play when I jumped back in, but now I feel let down, with her apparently not even showing interest in us or fight for us.

The problem with Keyla is that a lot of us have dated or known girls like her when we went to highschool and college and her story goes the exact way it does in real life. She has the perfect guy but ends up with another guy only to divorce years later then reappears in your life like magic regretting everything she did to you and hoping for a second chance.

 

[Semak34]

The problem with Keyla is that a lot of us have dated or known girls like her when we went to highschool and college and her story goes the exact way it does in real life. She has the perfect guy but ends up with another guy only to divorce years later then reappears in your life like magic regretting everything she did to you and hoping for a second chance.

View attachment 5450756

She should be at the bottom of my list alongside Kim, but I like her character design, so...

 

[Malicre]

She should be at the bottom of my list alongside Kim, but I like her character design, so...
View attachment 5451081

 

[Dessolos]

Haven't played in a couple chapters, and I planned to when dev did slight rework, got lost with other VNs and other stuff, then planned to come back for ch.4, but reading some of this about Keyla has me worried. She isn't my favorite but I actually like her a lot, and was hoping she got some good stuff, but from sounds of it, she got shafted a bit.

Feels like this always happens to girls I really like, they just get treated like less and like they don't matter by devs most of time where they show favoritism to others.
So now I am sad, cause she was one of the girl's paths(A few in front of her) I was excited to play when I jumped back in, but now I feel let down, with her apparently not even showing interest in us or fight for us.

idk I thought ch 3 before the rework improved Keyla and I didn't like her before but she kind always been disliked by alot of players. I don't think that would stop the dev from giving her some good content I mean look at Kim she is the most hated but she still getting decent scenes from the look at things.

 

[Torunis]

from what I understand I think the dev miss understood the harem tag at first and used it for a throuple I forget if that was this game or another so I might be wrong but either way no harem

Ok, it sounds plausibly. Because "optional harem" was mentioned initially in this thread (by the author?) but now its abandoned.

She should be at the bottom of my list alongside Kim, but I like her character design, so...

I have similar "problem".
Sometimes it would be nice to swap characters so they would align perfectly - the most interesting girls would have the best visual design. But everyone would have different opinion which one look better.
Julia seems to be good mix of both.

 

[Quetzzz]

idk I thought ch 3 before the rework improved Keyla and I didn't like her before but she kind always been disliked by alot of players. I don't think that would stop the dev from giving her some good content I mean look at Kim she is the most hated but she still getting decent scenes from the look at things.

Honestly, I think most of Keyla's problems have to do with Zeke. It's not only about her settling for him, but also showing and telling us she's spineless and self-serving.
The dev could've used the MC's relationship with Alessa and her disappearing as a reason why they didn't hook up in college. Later his father dies, creating another circumstance where the timing isn't there to start a relationship... And then Kim swoops in and steals him away. This is the point where Keyla could settle for Zeke, who she got to know as the MC's friend during college.

 

[Scarlet42]

What's the logic behind wanting to break up Alessa and Vera?
I generally agree with most people on this, but I don't understand this.
What's so wrong about wanting to be with two beautiful women at the same time?
And we're not doing this secretly.

What's even more interesting is that the game's developer does this too...
He says that if you're not in a relationship with these two, they'll definitely break up?

Excuse me, but why?

I'm not saying they can't break up, but why is it that they're only in a relationship if we're in a relationship with them?
I enjoy relationships other than the main character in erotic games.
These two are my favorites, but for some reason, everyone wants them to break up...

 

[Quetzzz]

I'm not saying they can't break up, but why is it that they're only in a relationship if we're in a relationship with them?
I enjoy relationships other than the main character in erotic games.

I'm guessing it's because this relationship is an experiment for Alessa. I don't doubt she genuinely cares for Vera, but Vera doesn't have the equipment to keep her satisfied. It's a bit of a porn trope, sadly. You could even argue that Alessa only realizes this after meeting the MC again and thinking about what could've been.

These two are my favorites, but for some reason, everyone wants them to break up...

I don't... I would like nothing more than for them to be happy together.

 

[AVNplayer69]

What's the logic behind wanting to break up Alessa and Vera?
I generally agree with most people on this, but I don't understand this.
What's so wrong about wanting to be with two beautiful women at the same time?
And we're not doing this secretly.

What's even more interesting is that the game's developer does this too...
He says that if you're not in a relationship with these two, they'll definitely break up?

Excuse me, but why?

I'm not saying they can't break up, but why is it that they're only in a relationship if we're in a relationship with them?
I enjoy relationships other than the main character in erotic games.
These two are my favorites, but for some reason, everyone wants them to break up...

I'm completely with you on that, idk why people are hell bent on breaking them up when all 3 of them could be in a love triangle without any issues

 

[Malicre]

I'm completely with you on that, idk why people are hell bent on breaking them up when all 3 of them could be in a love triangle without any issues

When i played it and the way i took it is that it wouldn't be a full throuple relationship. Your character would just be an after thought, someone they would invite into their inner circle when the mood fits. It also came across that vera is the dominant and alessa the submissive and i just wasn't a fan of their dynamic.

I personally didn't like vera at all and until alessa breaks up with her i wont be playing her path either.

 

[metamorphMP]

When i played it and the way i took it is that it wouldn't be a full throuple relationship. Your character would just be an after thought, someone they would invite into their inner circle when the mood fits. It also came across that vera is the dominant and alessa the submissive and i just wasn't a fan of their dynamic.

I personally didn't like vera at all and until alessa breaks up with her i wont be playing her path either.

Same here. I will only be playing Alessa’s solo route.
Call me boring or old-fashioned, but I prefer monogamous routes to polygamy in this kind of games.

 

[Dessolos]

What's the logic behind wanting to break up Alessa and Vera?
I generally agree with most people on this, but I don't understand this.
What's so wrong about wanting to be with two beautiful women at the same time?
And we're not doing this secretly.

What's even more interesting is that the game's developer does this too...
He says that if you're not in a relationship with these two, they'll definitely break up?

Excuse me, but why?

I'm not saying they can't break up, but why is it that they're only in a relationship if we're in a relationship with them?
I enjoy relationships other than the main character in erotic games.
These two are my favorites, but for some reason, everyone wants them to break up...

I just prefer solo over throuples I have to really like both options to even consider a throuple or a threesome for that matter I dislike threesomes as well most of the time. There just has not been enough Vera content for me to like her she is just whatever to me right now. The only realtionship id be okay with as a throuple in this game would be some combination of Julia , Michelle or Oliva as I really like those 3 characters alot.

Tho I won't comment on the break up bit cause I forgot what the dev said but I feel like that isn't how it's going to work. As I swore the dev said they would just naturally break up if we are trying for the Alessa solo path and that sounds like it wouldn't be natural to me.

 

[Semak34]

What's so wrong about wanting to be with two beautiful women at the same time?

Haven't you considered that some players might only be romantically interested in one of the two? It's not that difficult to understand...

 

[Malicre]

The only realtionship id be okay with as a throuple in this game would be some combination of Julia , Michelle or Oliva as I really like those 3 characters alot.

Give me a michelle and alessa throuple.

 

[Zorro#34]

What's so wrong about wanting to be with two beautiful women at the same time?
And we're not doing this secretly.

1) I'm just very monogamous as far as relationships go, as opposed to no-strings-attached hookups. Threesomes? I'm all in! Throuples? Not so much.
2) Alessa is his ex, while he meets Vera for the first time, and had no say in them getting together. So, Vera is not his choice originally, and it feels to me like in a throuple she's a compromise he's willing to make to get back with Alessa, which is… not a good thing.

What's even more interesting is that the game's developer does this too...
He says that if you're not in a relationship with these two, they'll definitely break up?

Excuse me, but why?

I'm not saying they can't break up, but why is it that they're only in a relationship if we're in a relationship with them?

That's probably to make players who do pick their path feel good about being a good influence on the girls.