J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
I can say we can safely assume that these are the reasons why the spell didn't work on Nicole. 1. The spell hadn't mature enough and 2. Nicole had mix feelings towards MC (US).
The second is an assumption in case the spell was already mature when he was next to Nicole, although Marilyn claims that when that happened MC must have already been with Chloe, causing what we are theorizing (officially, the spell only happens in the Chloe is Strange route).

I'm actually excited on how these nightmares will play out.
Let's hope so. It's another theory of the future content that Orb can show us in the future parts, since it would be something original based on the probable clash in her psyche both due to Nicole's fear for the condition of her daughter and the mixed feelings she has about the forbidden relationship she has with MC (on the one hand, she can't deny the feelings she has for him, but on the other hand there are the regrets she must be feeling for being in a relationship with his daughter's (ex-)boyfriend).

Another thing to wait and see to find out. If Chloe was the real target, I'm curious about what she did to Marilyn in order for to execute her revenge theory plan. I didn't know that female bullies are the cruelest in high schools. That is an interesting fact.
Another possibility is that what Chloe really did to her was something imagined or misperceived by Marilyn, and that as time passed her memories magnified it. However, the few references Chloe makes to MC about Marilyn are not positive at all except in the route where Chloe is MC's faithful girlfriend, because in it those two girls spend some time in the ice cream shop while MC and Nicole enjoy that excursion in that coastal town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Optimus69420

Optimus69420

Member
Apr 11, 2023
339
372
The second is an assumption in case the spell was already mature when he was next to Nicole, although Marilyn claims that when that happened MC must have already been with Chloe, causing what we are theorizing (officially, the spell only happens in the Chloe is Strange route).
Ohhhh I see and get it now. What was the theory you mentioned that the spell exists in the other two paths, the 'Chloe is still my GF' & 'Chloe is not my GF'?


Let's hope so. It's another theory of the future content that Orb can show us in the future parts, since it would be something original based on the probable clash in her psyche both due to Nicole's fear for the condition of her daughter and the mixed feelings she has about the forbidden relationship she has with MC (on the one hand, she can't deny the feelings she has for him, but on the other hand there are the regrets she must be feeling for being in a relationship with his daughter's (ex-)boyfriend).
That's true. At this point, Nicole can't deny the feelings she has for MC (US) now since Nicole or MC (US) said "I love you" to each other.

Another possibility is that what Chloe really did to her was something imagined or misperceived by Marilyn, and that as time passed her memories magnified it. However, the few references Chloe makes to MC about Marilyn are not positive at all except in the route where Chloe is MC's faithful girlfriend, because in it those two girls spend some time in the ice cream shop while MC and Nicole enjoy that excursion in that coastal town.
If they're somewhat friendly to each other Marilyn's revenge on Chloe is somewhat a 50/50 of happening because I'm guessing her revenge storyline needs to happen in all three routes. Most likely Marilyn's revenge on John hast the huge percentage to happen in all three routes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J0K3RXXX

J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
Ohhhh I see and get it now. What was the theory you mentioned that the spell exists in the other two paths, the 'Chloe is still my GF' & 'Chloe is not my GF'?
That we know, all this is just a theory. However, considering that Marilyn confesses MC on the Chloe is Strange route that she made that spell at a time that is unavoidable in all possible routes of the game (when she took advantage of her psychic powers to enter in his mind during the morning of the Day 4), it is logical to think that the spell has also happened in the other two great routes of the game ("Chloe is still MC's girlfriend" and "Chloe is no longer MC's girlfriend") but MC wouldn't even know the spell existed nor would Marilyn suspect that it backfired and affected Chloe instead of Nicole.

If this theory is finally on target, I imagine that the spell on those routes will be discovered very soon when the normal medical methods to wake Chloe up don't work at all. Perhaps after that, Marilyn will have a hunch about what really happened and sneak into the Heavens' house to confirm her suspicions, at which point she will be caught by MC and will no longer be able to keep her dirty little secret to herself, having to confess to MC what she intended to do to him and Nicole. I imagine that this route will provoke a greater feeling of betrayal in MC, which could lead to a progressive distancing between MC and Marilyn, which would be even greater if during that game MC has few Marilyn relationship points.

If they're somewhat friendly to each other Marilyn's revenge on Chloe is somewhat a 50/50 of happening because I'm guessing her revenge storyline needs to happen in all three routes. Most likely Marilyn's revenge on John hast the huge percentage to happen in all three routes.
While this is another plausible theory, remember that it is less likely to actually happen than the one described above. After all, Marilyn is a curious character who is difficult to understand. All things considered, she is the closest thing to a Joker in this story. In the end, everything she's done throughout the game may have been just because she wanted to have fun, screwing over the other characters; or there may be something more serious motivating her actions, which could be what we're now theorizing: a twisted plan for revenge against someone from the Heavens family.
 

Optimus69420

Member
Apr 11, 2023
339
372
That we know, all this is just a theory. However, considering that Marilyn confesses MC on the Chloe is Strange route that she made that spell at a time that is unavoidable in all possible routes of the game (when she took advantage of her psychic powers to enter in his mind during the morning of the Day 4), it is logical to think that the spell has also happened in the other two great routes of the game ("Chloe is still MC's girlfriend" and "Chloe is no longer MC's girlfriend") but MC wouldn't even know the spell existed nor would Marilyn suspect that it backfired and affected Chloe instead of Nicole.

If this theory is finally on target, I imagine that the spell on those routes will be discovered very soon when the normal medical methods to wake Chloe up don't work at all. Perhaps after that, Marilyn will have a hunch about what really happened and sneak into the Heavens' house to confirm her suspicions, at which point she will be caught by MC and will no longer be able to keep her dirty little secret to herself, having to confess to MC what she intended to do to him and Nicole. I imagine that this route will provoke a greater feeling of betrayal in MC, which could lead to a progressive distancing between MC and Marilyn, which would be even greater if during that game MC has few Marilyn relationship points.
So overall Marilyn's spell is a theory for all three routes? Correct me if I'm wrong.


While this is another plausible theory, remember that it is less likely to actually happen than the one described above. After all, Marilyn is a curious character who is difficult to understand. All things considered, she is the closest thing to a Joker in this story. In the end, everything she's done throughout the game may have been just because she wanted to have fun, screwing over the other characters; or there may be something more serious motivating her actions, which could be what we're now theorizing: a twisted plan for revenge against someone from the Heavens family.
Marilyn is indeed a mysterious character. It would be a nice twist if the Marilyn revenge theory came true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J0K3RXXX

J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
btw is this game turn into supernatural game ?
Aside from Marilyn's psychic abilities, the game doesn't delve into the supernatural. However, I do recall that at one point it was theorized that a certain character in the game also had those kinds of abilities.

So overall Marilyn's spell is a theory for all three routes? Correct me if I'm wrong.
We only know what is stated by Marilyn in the Chloe is Strange route, so in the other major routes this would be a theory. But since the psychic camgirl confessed that she did it at a moment that occurs unavoidably in all possible routes of the game, that theory has a pretty good basis of being true.
 

J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
maybe but that path might get removed or altered if this goes to steam.
Why do you think that? If it's because the nature of the origin of Chloe's obsession with Beeman, he is indeed the one who enjoys her attention but he hasn't been the one who provoked it. Besides, they're both of legal age, so I don't think there would be any problem if Orb finally decided to release his game on Steam.
 

Optimus69420

Member
Apr 11, 2023
339
372
We only know what is stated by Marilyn in the Chloe is Strange route, so in the other major routes this would be a theory. But since the psychic camgirl confessed that she did it at a moment that occurs unavoidably in all possible routes of the game, that theory has a pretty good basis of being true.
I see and I get it now. Thank you for confirming the Marilyn spell theory in "Chloe is MC's GF & Chloe is not MC's GF anymore" is just a theory at the moment, J0K3RXXX! :love: :love:


Aside from Marilyn's psychic abilities, the game doesn't delve into the supernatural. However, I do recall that at one point it was theorized that a certain character in the game also had those kinds of abilities.
Do you happen to know or guess which character in AML has this ability?
 
  • Like
Reactions: J0K3RXXX

J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
Do you happen to know or guess which character in AML has this ability?
Personally I have no idea, so I'm open to any possibility Orb comes up with (if he does end up choosing that option for the future of AML's story), but I seem to recall that this was a theory that came up when that magic circle was shown under Chloe's bed in the Chloe is Strange route (which was the cliffhanger for Part 5 in that major route).
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Optimus69420

Optimus69420

Member
Apr 11, 2023
339
372
Personally I have no idea, so I'm open to any possibility Orb comes up with (if he does end up choosing that option for the future of AML's story), but I seem to recall that this was a theory that came up when that magic circle was shown under Chloe's bed in the Chloe is Strange route (which was the cliffhanger for Part 5 in that major route).
Ohhh, I see. I'm sure dev Orb will surely make it a surprise to who is that character that has the supernatural ability. It will certainly be a twist.

Do you think this character that has the supernatural ability be exclusive to the 'Chloe is Strange' route or will it be available for all of the routes?
 
  • Like
Reactions: J0K3RXXX

J0K3RXXX

Engaged Member
Dec 7, 2018
2,095
1,220
Ohhh, I see. I'm sure dev Orb will surely make it a surprise to who is that character that has the supernatural ability. It will certainly be a twist.

Do you think this character that has the supernatural ability be exclusive to the 'Chloe is Strange' route or will it be available for all of the routes?
Please note that this is just a fan theory. There is no certainty that Orb will place another character with those psychic abilities in future parts of AML, but if Marilyn has them, it is possible that there are more characters like that, and if so, it is most likely someone related to Marilyn herself. Perhaps that is why neither her grandmother nor any of her parents have been shown yet.

So this is all fan speculation.

However, if more characters with those abilities do eventually appear in the Chloe is Strange route, I think they should appear in the rest of the game's routes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Optimus69420

Optimus69420

Member
Apr 11, 2023
339
372
Please note that this is just a fan theory. There is no certainty that Orb will place another character with those psychic abilities in future parts of AML, but if Marilyn has them, it is possible that there are more characters like that, and if so, it is most likely someone related to Marilyn herself. Perhaps that is why neither her grandmother nor any of her parents have been shown yet.

So this is all fan speculation.

However, if more characters with those abilities do eventually appear in the Chloe is Strange route, I think they should appear in the rest of the game's routes.
Of course, I haven't forgotten it's just a theory, and noted I may have forgotten it in a second. I'm just saying it will be a twist and a surprise if this theory will happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J0K3RXXX

FGM01

Member
Jun 27, 2023
259
108
I never play these 3D style games, cause the people always look weird and I dont like it. But Nicole convinced me to make this my first, and I have no regrets. It's really good, even though compared to her the others still look a bit unnatural. Seems like most of the focus went to her design.
 
4.30 star(s) 225 Votes