- Apr 11, 2023
- 346
- 391
This theory is very interesting. We discussed it before, and I misinterpreted it at the time as Marilyn using her spell to get Nicole all for herself. It's my fault, and my brain processes things slowly.About this comment, I don't know if you know that there is an interesting fan theory about it. In this theory, Chloe has been affected in all the major routes by the spell performed by Marilyn whose final intention was to make Nicole fall madly in love with MC (she took advantage of the morning of Day 4, when she sneaked into MC's bedroom to rummage through his mind, an event that occurs in all possible routes of the game), but its outcome varies in each major route of the game:
What do you think of the theory?
- In the routes where Chloe cheats on MC with their disgusting History teacher (the routes titled "Chloe is Strange" and "Chloe is no longer MC's girlfriend"), MC has neglected and/or lied to Chloe enough for her to fall into this affair with Beeman. This would be because when the spell MC carried inside him was unleashed on the person closest to MC, it was not Nicole but Chloe, and since her feelings towards MC were of a negative nature, the spell remained hibernating inside her waiting for someone to provoke positive feelings of that type, something that only happened when she was with Beeman. That would explain the obsessive fanaticism with which Chloe accepts her forbidden affair with Beeman. The crucial difference between the two routes is based on the player's choice after MC discovers on Day 6 the affair between his girlfriend and his History teacher, during a talk with Marilyn:
- If the player chooses the option of not forgetting Chloe, MC will maintain the relationship with her and during Day 10 he will notice the differences in how she treats him and Beeman sexually, which will generate doubts that he will raise with Marilyn, who will try to dismiss them until Day 13 when MC discovers a magic circle under Chloe's bed and questions Marilyn about it, who confesses her twisted secret plan and how it must have backfired. This is the route known as Chloe is Strange.
- If the player chooses to forget Chloe once and for all, MC will accept the facts and decides to focus exclusively on Nicole, as Marilyn has recommended to him. As a result, Chloe will break up with him after her family dinner at the steakhouse on Day 7 and they will each go their separate ways, except when Chloe wants to give the impression to her parents that they are still together in order to hide her true relationship with Beeman. Since MC is no longer in a relationship with Chloe, he won't notice Chloe's differences in sexual treatment when it comes to him versus Beeman. This is the route known as Chloe is no longer MC's girlfriend, and neither MC nor Marilyn should suspect that there is a badly done spell by Marilyn because MC would not know anything and Marilyn would believe that it has gone well, given the progress of the relationship between MC and Nicole, and that the progress of the affair between Chloe and Beeman is due to the fact that she must be resentful of MC and for that reason she has become entangled with the man that MC hates the most.
- In the route where Chloe remains MC's faithful girlfriend, Marilyn's spell would have been triggered when MC was near Chloe, and since she had positive feelings of that kind towards MC, the spell worked perfectly on her, directing all her affection towards him despite the various future moments where he cuts short their moments together to be with his beloved Nicole. Therefore, he would not know about the existence of a spell cast on Chloe as he would believe that the lovestruck Chloe is still in love with him, without anything strange driving her to do so. Meanwhile, in Marilyn's case, she would not believe that her spell backfired because she does know about the continued progress of the forbidden relationship between MC and Nicole and Chloe's behavior would seem to her to be that of a girl in love with her boyfriend, without knowing or catching a glimpse of the closeness between him and her mother.
My only question is why would Marilyn go to the trouble of making a spell to make Nicole fall in love with the MC (Us)? Does she have no confidence in MC (Us) that MC (Us) couldn't court Nicole?
I'm so glad Marilyn's spell backfires in all three routes with Chloe because if the spell were ever to succeed, then Nicole's character development for her feelings towards MC (Us) would've been ruined and wouldn't be called a natural love story between MC (Us) and Nicole. It would ruin their relationship and love story, in my opinion.
Thank you soo much for sharing this MAGO-DAG!!You must be registered to see the links
View attachment 4396832
View attachment 4396833
View attachment 4396835
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And Happy New Year Everyone!!!