Carl Sagan 42
Newbie
- May 29, 2025
 
- 37
 
- 29
 
- 37
 
First of all, John is my favorite character in the game. He is the only one who has remained unchanged no matter the circumstances. Now, to answer your question: in Part 10, when the MC and Silvia visit the clothing store run by Alicia, she raises a very important question — why would John appoint a male in his office? She is surprised to see the MC, as she had never seen any male worker at Magic Grand. All those who work there are alluring women, and we know what purposes John uses them for. So, unless there is a very special reason, John would not appoint the MC.In many stories featuring married women, the narrative often revolves around a man pursuing a relationship just to claim his love and take her away from her uncaring husband. However, this story feels so different. John is a character about whom you can never be sure what he is thinking. He excels at playing with your mind while simultaneously making it seem like he isn't really doing anything against you. Yes, you could say he is a ruthless businessman, but aside from that, what evil actions has he committed against the mc? The main character's mother even went to him for help herself. He impregnated the bar owner's wife, but the backstory shows it was the wife's wish because she desired him. John accepted the main character as his daughter's boyfriend and treated him with respect, even offering him a good job at his company. What did he get in return? The mc cheated on his daughter with her mother and is now trying to undermine him. Not to mention, it is never really made clear whether he actually knows about the main character's affair with Nicole, which gives off such a playing with fire feeling to the story really a well wrote character overall
I personally believe the MC is John’s son. Though we don’t have much proof to support this, there are some hints. One of those I just mentioned. Another is John calling him “son.” And if you remember, Alicia also mentions more than a couple of times that they both sound similar. Also one more thing I believe Chloe is not John and Nichole's daughter.