VN Ren'Py Completed A Promise Best Left Unkept [Bonus S2 Ep 9-11] [Hangover Cat]

4.10 star(s) 104 Votes
Discussion Reviews (104)
NTR Sommelier

NTR Sommelier

Member
May 29, 2022
154
404
Terix3 said:
Atalier Sakura games are netorase not netorare, sorry i just don't play their games they got nothing to offer for me. What is even good ending in netorase game? Or maybe it is easier to ask what is bad ending in netorase game given that any ending where MC gets cucked is good one since that is what he desired. (not a serious question just emphasis on how different those two genres are).

Like i said there will be good ending and one is enough to get that "what he is missing feel". In case you wanted it to be earlier ending - I will remind that ending order past normal one was decided by vote.

@ taking away from the drama - If you don't like good ending you can just not play it, so in that sense it doesn't take away (some people just don't want to see MC happy). However it is taking away from content, every "vanilla" scene is one ntr scene less. So understandably people that get nothing out of good endings will be against spending resources on those.

@ Scars of Summer - that may be on purpose, the game is about anguish of powerlessly watching others have fun with the girl, while MC did not even confess his feelings. Having route where MC has time with girl would be a form of comfort and thus taking away from the main goal of the game.
Click to expand...
You are wrong. There are true NTR Games from Atelier Sakura, like this one:
images.jpeg
 
  • Like
  • Red Heart
Reactions: crisbr, Shatteredstar, Lewist and 3 others
Joshy92

Joshy92

Devoted Member
Mar 25, 2021
9,540
20,463
All this talk about lack of agency has me thinking that maybe that's why I don't really play NTR games.
Except for I think three games on here

I'm the kind of guy who likes games that have tons of different choices to shape the mc into my kind of person.
And I have found I normally don't get that In NTR or harem games.
It certainly makes me think anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: armyman654 and JoZEr
Z

ZUBiDAM

Member
Apr 6, 2022
396
639
Terix3 said:
Let me guess, does not have English translation ? Does it have any relevance for the discussion about good endings?
Every their game that I've come across here was netorase and assuming you are self inserting. Not my type of games.
Click to expand...
sometimes they have netorase that turn more into netorare, like a bad ending
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shatteredstar
T

Terix3

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2017
1,040
1,524
NTR Sommelier said:
Translation or not. You claimed Atelier Sakura is all Netorase. That claim is wrong.
Click to expand...
They are known for their netorase games... that better?

Let me correct myself here too ...
Shatteredstar said:
'Light' agency is part of the genre. It's easy to point at Atelier Sakura games, but they're not irrelevant. Their games vary wildly from kinetic to two or more endings. When they have more endings on offer, normally one is a 'good' ending. Players get to see what could have been. Sometimes that comes with a lovey sex scene, but always with story details. The credits are reached quickly so the effort is minimal, but it satisfies the want of agency. I agree that normally, if at all, there are few good endings in this genre. Many times those endings are not really 'good' just the relationship between MC and MH doesn't fail immediately. Something like they are together still and most likely the next baby, after the one growing inside her is born, will be MC's.
Click to expand...
Are you talking about netorase or netorare games? Because I've not played any Atelier Sakura netorare game let alone one with multiple good endings.

Some people just ignore the point and focus on some inconsistency irrelevant for the discussion resident-sleeper.png
 
G

ginelofki

Member
Feb 29, 2020
233
149
i prefer my ntr like my coffee with dirty talk, suggestion and manipulation, rape is a cheap move of a script to any ntr
FzIBu9QWAAAXy_U.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.10 star(s) 104 Votes