- Apr 12, 2018
- 10,932
- 7,366
...Ok let's entertain you a bit more, I'll start from the end since it seems easier to go this way.What "most important question" are you referring to? That isn't a rhetorical question. I genuinely want to know.
Because the reason why I said the "holiness" or "darkness" of the Golem origin is irrelevant here, is because the original discussion that was being had here was simply about creating and magically animating clay creatures.
So my original assertion, that this kind of magic is more akin to Jewish Golem magic rather than necromancy or voodoo, is still correct.
In addition, @Chyos could ultimately decide in his own tale whether to make Golems holy or dark, thus making the "holiness" or "darkness" of the Golem's origins even more irrelevant.
It is you that tries to bring in storylore by combining it with myth... I can't recall any discussions about Voodoo being done in the Posts I quoted as that stuff was discussed much earlier and ended with the same conclusion as before... to much effort for no apparent gain and several loopholes and story breaches... bringing up a dead horse to ride it again may fit the zombie Golems you have spoken of so far but it doesn't help with either the discussion nor makeing a point.
I suspect you never worked with your hands in that pattern than... molding anything usuable requires knowledge of the material and skill... it's one thing to paint a stone wall with clay as mortar and something completly different useing clay to form an artistic body double.Or just have the MC mold a man/figure out of clay and then use the magic he learned from Gwen & Sabrina to animate it.
Don't see the need for a fully-automated factory to build a single man of clay.
Many artists have been able to create such a thing without the need of all the resources you've mentioned.
You're argument is like saying that the building of the second story to Emily's house shouldn't have happened because the technological know-how and equipment wouldn't have been available to medieval townsmen.
I think you're forgetting this is a fantasy game, not a historically accurate rendition of the middle ages.
And what skill does the MC have that would allow him to animate something inanimate?
Soul steal?... yeah that's not gonna fly far.