Paladin's don't lie to woman. If they are involved with another woman they tell each other about the other woman in his life. If Mira finds about Heather or Emily, she is hurt by that. That means if you have sex with anyone woman other than Mira, you are not being a paladin to Mira.
Same with Penny. Hell even Gwen is annoyed when she finds out about Sabrina. You can offer this Islam rule that four are okay, but the woman themselves are not okay with that. Very few of them are okay with the MC screwing around, which means if you sleep with anyone other than them, you are not a paladin.
And even if you play ASWS were you only have sex with four woman, and are not ever dishonest to any of them, you are cutting the content down to about three hours of game play.
No matter how much you have played this game, you can not deny that.
Like I said last night, I love this game, but the MC is not a paladin.
In Islam, you are allowed 4 marriages at same time. No one said I can't divorce anyone. They can divorce so can I because of their horrible behaviour or anything else. Of course the women must be told before hand the rule and they must be married to first to have any sexual relationship at all. And I have seen few women in real life who are okay with it and they were even christians for that matter. Heck Mormons have multiple wives more than 4 that they marry that I know of. All before hand well informed of the rule and such.
Anyway
Hmm let's see who fits that criteria in the game at the moment.
I can play Gwen's content up to till I get Athia bounded in mortal form. The moment you sided with Athia Gwen no longer acknowledges you anymore. Sort of Divorced already from her at that point.
Athia have no issue for MC to have more women, she acknowledges that part before saying she and MC is bonded together forever. Frisha have no issues. Julia have no issues. There are few others who have no issues at all for it.
And I shall repeat, you can mold the MC as much as you want. It's your choice. You can drink from Chalice to make himeven go on dark path as Chyos said in the guide even. What ever you want MC to be it is. You can steal money from every chest or not at all. It's all your choice. Doesn't mean MC is a theif for all playthroughs. Only thing that he steals directly for quests completing rest is purely choice.
Relax and enjoy the game. I am playing that playthrough less content don't worry about it. Game can be played with harem with all the women of the game too. No one is stopping you at all. You might have missed my post about Athia vsGwen route temple maybe. It's a game, not real life. But real life portion of 4 wives rule can be applied to play a run through easily too as a paladin.
Game is not even completed, so less content doesn't mean it can't be played like that. It can be just limited things that is all. It's a personal choice for run through. Relax