Certainly, if I had just discovered AWAM last week, it's possible that I wouldn't have downloaded it, or more likely would have downloaded & played once, before deleting. I've tried most of the AWAM substitutes, or AWAM-inspired games & have kept none of them. AWAM for the first few years had, IMO, the potential to be (& was for a time), truly outstanding erotica. That's how it was from my POV & the pace of development meant that it didn't matter if some updates contained little or nothing of interest. When it slowed to a snail's pace & evolved into just another average teen porn game, due to last up to another 40 years, my enthusiasm waned.
Oddly, perhaps, none of the games I deleted were ditched because of the inclusion of incest but it is the case, however, that I just can't find it appealing. That may be a consequence of my tastes in porn being formed when it didn't have much of a presence & there was no "teen porn," only "porn" & that was for adults, even if it featured a cast of teens as large as that of AWAM, as did one of the first stories I remember reading, which featured a teacher & her class of evil, wayward students.