Hi. Ref your 4th paragraph and concerns of AWAM/blackmail becoming a consensual sex game.
Well of course AWAM is already a sex game, though IMO not a porn game despite claims by many. Nothing wrong with that, and way better for it.
From the start it set out to be a game about sex, specifically about the life, desires and sexual liberation of married woman called Sophia Parker. The loosely worded "corruption" implies she will finish as a slut which I believe most people don't want at all.
From your comments it's clear you strongly favour the concept of blackmail as a route to achieve this or at least you appear to express this as a personal preference. Criticisms of which have come from those tired of seeing blackmail across the board as a sex motivator from countless other games, so might rank it over-used and unimaginative.
Personally I don't do similar games, AWAM is really the only one I have any interest in, so the Aiden blackmail thing for me is quite acceptable as a mover and motivator within the context of this story. I'd certainly hate to see it removed, not that I believe it will, and that all 12 tasks will be completed, probably as the finale to this game.
But meanwhile, Sophia is already well on the way to finding pleasure from being manipulated in this way from Aiden the school bully, so I don't quite understand your objection, as you can't change it now. I see this switch as a natural progression, exactly as L&P intended.
So, as far as Sophia discovering and re-discovering her inner desires by way of the deal struck, Aiden should be congratulated. It is almost like the two are having an affair, only an exclusive, complicit and mutually pleasurable one without Sophia ever admitting it. A thrilling affair some married individuals might inwardly desire which can, and quite often actually does save rather than destroy marriages nearing the end of their shelf-life.
I don't think you have anything to worry about L&P pulling the plug on blackmail, but even he knows that setting increasingly impossible demands for Sophia might become either impractical or unrealistic, or worse still become tiresome to many following this thread. One thing L&P has always been wary of is rarely repeating scenarios or dramas as if flogging a dead horse. We might not always like it, but he's always kept followers guessing, stopped vital threads becoming stale, as any good writer should.
As for the dangers of Sophia becoming mutually sexually complicit with Aiden. As we know, that is already partly established. Fortunately for the pro-blackmailing lobby Sophia would never admit to it, so you are on perfectly safe ground.
When I started playing this game/VN it promised to be a story of a woman embarking on some extra-marital sexual adventures but with a level of realism unseen in the genre. So far, so good. After a time I began to perceive that the story was largely about incest, rather than extra-marital activity in the generally accepted sense of the term. Still, it had higher quality renders, (by a considerable margin at the time), than other games & the characters weren't puerile, (apart from the actual kids), as with so many populating the 3d render world. It seemed that there was an overall plan & that it could last 3-4 years, so I stuck with it. Above all, I was after an erotic story written by an adult for other adults.
Straightforward porn was a thing of the past for me. It wasn't that I'd become jaded but rather that I enjoyed a good story rather than 'shag everything that moves' trash. I feel the same about the cinema, preferring a decent script, good direction, high production values & proper acting, to the, "Well Mrs Parker, that's your sink fixed, let's fuck", variety of tosh. I will admit, however, that porn had become boring to me, probably because I read my first porn story in 1965. You could say that apart from changing fashions in clothes, it lacked novelty from my POV. 3d was a way of telling a story that I felt had never achieved anything like it's potential in the field of eroticism. AWAM was set fair to aim for that goal.
As it was a visual novel with a slow burn aura of pending eroticism, it fit the bill for me. As potential partners or sexual contacts were introduced, I found that I could either avoid the incest, or if necessary, just ignore it & move on. At this time, IMO, AWAM was a work of great promise. So what went wrong?
Well, not everything & with interesting characters, occasional good writing, excellent renders & a completely fanciable MC, combining beauty, brains & numerous talents from academia to sport via music, it's easy to see why I'm still here.
I have the same problem as everyone else when it comes to the update schedule, so I won't labour the point. We all get it but there's nothing we can do about it.
I suppose it could be said that I'm too picky when it comes to erotic literature, especially contemporary offerings. There are more plotlines, tropes, kinks & byways that I don't like than those I do. AWAM already had incest, which doesn't interest me but then more 'issues' came along, as L&P appeared intent on covering a wide range of stock scenarios. One element that I did appreciate, however, was blackmail. Once introduced it attracted a tirade of criticism, white-knighting & righteous, or self-righteous indignation. I began to defend its' inclusion. There are many posts discussing various aspects of it, by me & others, so again, I won't repeat myself.
Blackmail started to get results in driving the story forward & from my POV introduced a power surge of erotic scenes. I certainly don't want Sophia corrupted to the point of becoming a slut but nor do I want to see her & Aiden running down a hillside, holding hands & laughing. There's a fine balance to be struck, which I believe has so far been admirably achieved but may be under threat now. Evidence for what I consider 'anti-sophistication' is mounting, more than likely driven by the age profile of L&Ps paying audience. I don't want introspection along the lines of, 'this is so wrong but it feels so good....what am I doing?" etc., from Sophia. That's not how people think, except in porn stories. I didn't want Sophia to suddenly change her physical appearance to appeal to lovers of stereotypes & who still think that if a mature woman's breasts are large enough & you squeeze them, or apply a machine, you'll get milk.
Blackmail's not just there to ease the path to corruption, it's also there to fulfil the fantasy of having a degree of control over a gorgeous, sophisticated woman. That's one aspect I enjoy & which looks set to disappear in a miasma of mutual consent. I don't care if other fans are revolted by that, because I can't be kink-shamed & indeed refuse to be disapproved of by lovers of incest, shota etc., which arguably are just as over-used & unimaginative as blackmail. I'm very tolerant of other's tastes & respect them but that's not how blackmail is necessarily dealt with in this thread. What influence the chorus of disapproval has had on the VN we'll never know but I have my suspicions.
Finishing on a positive note, I admire your optimism in believing that the tasks will be completed. I don't think they will be, making the whole issue academic but I certainly hope to be proved wrong.