It comes down to in-game logic. One of the main reasons I don't play the Aidem path is that it makes no sense to me that a smart, resourceful woman like Sophia could succumb to a mere school bully like Aiden. Knowing full well when threatened she has a resourceful, and rich bother-in-law like Carl.
As for Sunday, we've already been told that's a full day event with Patricia at her friend's horse ranch
I hate the Aidan path too, but I still play through all versions again to transfer all storylines (ie with and without Aidan) to Part 2. Luckily there is a skip button.
I think there was a mistake made early on in the Aidan Sophia storyline that led to misconceptions. You only have 2 choices: GoodWife or Filthy. Goodwife always leads to cancellation and Dylan goes to boarding school. Filthy, on the other hand, always suggests sexual pleasure. Unfortunately, you always have to choose this option if you don't want to send Dylan to boarding school.
This often leads to contradictory reactions, between she is disgusted and she is wet.
There should always have been 3 choices here. Goodwife, as usual, cancels everything.
The 2nd with Filthy +. In which Sophia seems to like being sexually humiliated and sexually bullied. So everything that the Aidan fans believe and want.
And my 3rd choice with Filthy -. So in both Filthy choices, you do as Aidan asks. But in the negative version, all the disgust she feels comes out.
I would have included these 3 options in the Sophia Aidan path. So for me there is always only the choice between Dylan to boarding school or mafia against Aidan. There won't be a version for me where he ends up getting what he wants.