- Feb 14, 2018
- 1,425
- 4,912
Ok, I get that Dylan COULD do something to knock her down a peg, but if he did do that wouldn't that make him more unlikeable? In other words, in a narrative sense, how does this help the story move along or serve his or Ellie's character development? They are both competitive, engage in fairly typical brother and sister spats and teasing and (surprisingly, almost unbelievably, for such good looking teenagers) sexually inexperienced, but we already know that.Catch Ellie and Christine with some sex toys and that's enough. At least the "perv brother" part goes away.
If Dylan takes a swing at her what are we learning besides that Dylan is a spiteful and/or jealous prick? If that punch lands, what does that do to Ellie? break her? push her further into her mother's comforting embrace? or Julia's arms? or cause her to escalate (revenge)? Seems like the middle two are happening already without agitation from Dylan so while it could add another dimension it doesn't change the fact of the matter. The first and fourth, while fun and possibly interesting, are very big distractions from what we really want to see.