I'm late to this party too and oh how I wish I'd found this game sooner, I absolutely loved it!
Melissa got my vote for being exactly the type I'd normally go for but I had to put in a vote for Liam as well - the first friend character to ever make me choose them over sex with a hot girl!
Same! Just discovered this masterpiece, also voted for Melissa & Liam The only time I really felt anything for Megan was when I had to make the dreaded "choice"
For me it's Melissa/Rena and then Megan. Liam is a very cool dude
Could bed nice is you could date only Melissa, and Megan as a friend
Love the game, it's very fun