Recommending An annoyed fucking user's Tier List of Games with Actual Gameplay [150+ games rated]

4.70 star(s) 7 Votes
May 30, 2021
55
573
I'm sick of Visual Novels, Kinetic Novels, click-all-the-options-to-see-the-porn-games, RPG maker shovelware, and the likes. Hundreds of threads here and on reddit show that there is a demand for porn games that are actual, you know, fucking games. But theres no exhaustive list. Last night I got sufficiently pissed that I decided to make my own.

This list is going to be highly subjective. This list is going to be built up over time. This list will not feature generic ass 3d models (unless they are tied to good gameplay), generic ass japanese art that looks like it was photocopied from one of the other 4000 japanese shovelware games (unless its tied to good gameplay). This list will not attempt to be consistent in its distinction between visual novels/click to get the porn games and management games because its fluid as fuck, so I'm going by feel, if you don't like the way I included it fuck you, deal with it.

Update 2022-03-21: I will divide games into three categories, "platformers", "non-platformers" (because a lot of these are platformers), and "3D" (referring to actual 3D games, not 3D renders). I am lumping certain sidescrollers in with platformers. Do give the non-platformers category a go, there is some creative stuff in there. (Unfortunately not enough, though). Within these I will use the following tiers:

  • S-Tier: These games have great gameplay and great porn.
  • A-Tier: These games have either good gameplay and great porn, or great gameplay and good porn.
  • B-Tier: These games are above average and enjoyable in either gameplay or porn.
  • C-Tier: These games are average and mostly unremarkable, or they have some flaws that make a higher tier unjustifiable. Play these after you are done with the upper tiers.
  • D-Tier: These games are below average in some respects, but you might still be able to draw some enjoyment from them. This usually means the gameplay is bad, since a bad art style can be compensated by good gameplay easier than the other way around.
  • F-Tier: These games are garbage. Do not play.
  • Other: These do not fit in the above scheme, usually because I have not played them and I do not want to rate games I have not played. They might also not fit the criteria of being either interesting or having good gameplay (i.e. they might be RPGmaker trash), but I still want to give my opinion on them. (Looking at you, Queen Opala.)

I will roughly attempt to order these within category by quality, but that is difficult. This ordering is more accurate in the higher tiers.
I would like to emphasize that this list is ultimately subjective. If you don't like it, go find another list.

Another user pointed out that I seem to prefer Female Protagonist / Male Domination games. This may be accurate. I tend to have long edging sessions when playing these, so I'm generally looking for something that gives me constant eye candy. I favor background characters with slutty clothes over long, drawn out sex scenes.

I also don't like goblins. They are not real monsters and make it unnecessarily difficult to find proper monster fucking.

With that in mind, here you go:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.




You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.




You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.




You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.




You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.


Finally, do check out the suggestions by other users in this thread. They might not always match my tastes, but they might match yours.

Finally, a word of advice on how to filter out most of the garbage to find good games easier:
  • Go to the latest updates page.
  • In "Engine", either choose "Unity" (and maybe "Other"), or filter out RPGM and Renpy. There are sometimes good, fappable games (or even engaging VNs) made in Renpy, and rarely there are good RPGM games. But the vast majority of good porn games are made with Unity. (And some of the good Japnese games use their own weird engines, hence "Other").
  • In Prefix "Other", filter out "VN". This is the single most important filter.
  • In "Prefix: Status", filter out "Abandoned" and "On hold".
  • Obviously, you can also use tags associated with gameplay to find proper games. "Platformer" and "Sidescroller" are obvious choices, but there is still a lot of shovelware. It is generally also worth excluding "3dcg".
Cheers.
 
Last edited:

Pretentious Goblin

Devoted Member
Nov 3, 2017
9,185
7,697
News Desk is actually quite good. Well, the card game is. The interludes in the city just reward mind-numbing grind.

Behind the Dune is terrible in terms of gameplay. RTS are an ill-begotten bastardization of the strategy genre, and even then it's easy to see why the game that BtD is based on is not the one that made them popular. It's just kind of a footnote.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaleFixer
May 11, 2020
28
33
Honestly skyrim special edition changes everything, if you haven't tried it in a while I would recommend to try it out.

I used to play on normal edition. Lag, crashing and around level 30-40 my load times would exceed a mintue.

Change over to special edition and I can play if ENBs, consistent frame rate and the game is mostly stable. I mean I get some crashes every now and then but with the amount of mods I'm using I'll take it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: saeid90
May 30, 2021
55
573
Honestly skyrim special edition changes everything, if you haven't tried it in a while I would recommend to try it out.

I used to play on normal edition. Lag, crashing and around level 30-40 my load times would exceed a mintue.

Change over to special edition and I can play if ENBs, consistent frame rate and the game is mostly stable. I mean I get some crashes every now and then but with the amount of mods I'm using I'll take it.
I tried legendary edition and it was pretty unstable. Also took forever to set up. Maybe I should try special edition at some point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ***Hunter***

test011

Member
Jan 10, 2018
117
253
I'd add Venus Blood: Frontier to at least "good" tier since it has actual gameplay. Choosing your units equipment and setting up squads is quite fun, although strategy layer is quite simple it still makes for an okay "Risk" style game.

Also speaking of other games with gameplay:
EraTohoK - Dwarf Fortress of Ero games some might say, strategy layer and management layer, entirely text based but really free form and open.
Free Cities - Another text based game, this time its mostly slave/city management. Gameplay not super complex but its something.
Lilith Throne - Update Soon™, another text based game, has turn based combat element in it, itemization and randomization are present.
 
Last edited:
May 30, 2021
55
573
My ongoing game Apocalypse is actually a GAME.
I'll be honest, that art style is hardcore not my thing

You wot? Those are some the most fun porn games out there, especially if you like the whole rapey goblin genre
Iirc burrow was badly translated and just wasn't my thing. Walker had super simplistic gameplay and tiny animations, I think? Idk been along time since I played it. I do sorta not like goblins because they get tagged as "monster" in every other shitty japanese crapgame when they are the only "monster" content and not what I look for in a game tagged "monster".

I'd add Venus Blood: Frontier to at least "good" tier since it has actual gameplay. Choosing your units equipment and setting up squads is quite fun, although strategy layer is quite simple it still makes for an okay "Risk" style game.

Also speaking of other games with gameplay:
EraTohoK - Dwarf Fortress of Ero games some might say, strategy layer and management layer, entirely text based but really free form and open.
Free Cities - Another text based game, this time its mostly slave/city management. Gameplay not super complex but its something.
Lilith Throne - Update Soon™, another text based game, has turn based combat element in it, itemization and randomization are present.
I tried Venus Blood Frontier at some point, it fails the generic japanese art and VN criteria.
My arbitrary criteria further exclude text based games, because reading. Although I am fascinated that EraTohoK is something that exists, I was not aware of it before.

edit: I added some more games that I had forgotten
 
Last edited:

Ross_69

Member
Feb 2, 2019
147
123
Last Sovereign is like one of my top games ever, not just NSFW. I guess it's battle gameplay is not that great, but it's management aspect, and plot with a lot of choices, are one of the best in any RPG.

Brothel City is like Settlers, but with porn.

Midnight Castle Succubus is pretty good metroidvania I think (haven't played it for a while), and it's porn is pretty interesting (Pixel Art).

Also, post about good games, and no mention of Rance? How could it be? It's not only a classic Eroge, but one with multiple titles that have good gameplay.
 
May 30, 2021
55
573
try town of magic
Tried this at some point and didn't get very far into it, I'll put it back on the todo list

Do management sims count?

I find Mystwood Manor's gameplay somehow engaging. And the production value of it is top tier.

https://f95zone.to/threads/mystwood-manor-v0-6-0-full-faerin.42940/

I'm sorry but this just looks generic as fuck. I can't play another 3dcgs incest game

Last Sovereign is like one of my top games ever, not just NSFW. I guess it's battle gameplay is not that great, but it's management aspect, and plot with a lot of choices, are one of the best in any RPG.

Brothel City is like Settlers, but with porn.

Midnight Castle Succubus is pretty good metroidvania I think (haven't played it for a while), and it's porn is pretty interesting (Pixel Art).

Also, post about good games, and no mention of Rance? How could it be? It's not only a classic Eroge, but one with multiple titles that have good gameplay.
Last sovereign: I thought this only had text based sex scenes but apparently it doesn't? Did images get added at some point or am I confusing it for another game? I'll put it on the todo list but since its RPGM, no promises

Brothel City: Not my thing personally and hard for me to judge, but I'll put it in the post, it deserves to be there

Midnight Castle Succubus (and related): I've played some of these, not my favorites, but deserve to be on the list as well

Rance: Too japanese
 

Ross_69

Member
Feb 2, 2019
147
123
Last sovereign: I thought this only had text based sex scenes but apparently it doesn't? Did images get added at some point or am I confusing it for another game? I'll put it on the todo list but since its RPGM, no promises
Yeah, Last Sovereign got the images added later, for majority of it's existence it was text-based.

I played it when it didn't have them, and I still played it until I got to where the content ends (which is few tens of hours), because it's non-porn aspects were just that great.

And now it has both the story and mechanics that kept me for the whole playthrough, and actual pictures for sex.

As a side note, RPGM got bad rep, but it's just an engine and games for it can be mad good. Not porn related, but Fear & Hunger has a great gameplay, while being RPGM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pretentious Goblin

F4C430

Active Member
Dec 4, 2018
650
745
FYI the Agnietta in your "Good/Okay" list is actually Chinese, not Japanese.

I'm sick of Visual Novels, Kinetic Novels, click-all-the-options-to-see-the-porn-games, RPG maker shovelware, and the likes.
Amen
 
  • Like
Reactions: weradti

aza416

Newbie
Jun 9, 2020
28
39
Last Evil - Card game with similar gameplay to Slay the Spire

I see that you rejected Rance. Well, this is your list, you have all the right to do so. For me personally, Sengoku Rance is the first porn game that got me hooked into porn game
 
4.70 star(s) 7 Votes