Personally, I decided that I wanted Anna to split up with Andrew, a long time before the kidnapping. There are so many things I don't like about him. The problem the Devs have, is that they need Andrew to stay in the story, so Anna has somebody to cheat on. But unfortunately they've made him so unlikeable, that a lot of people just want him to be gone. And I understand why Deep kind of did that, because it makes it infinitely easier for the players to overlook that Anna is basically a cheating whore. Because most people just don't feel bad for Andrew at all.
I disagree though about Anna being dependant on Andrew, I think it's more the other way round actually. To a certain extent Anna feels that she owes something to Andrew, because he helped her cope with her drunken Father, before both of them moved to Sun City. And I think that's why she's reluctant to just give up on him, without hearing what he's got to say about the kidnapping. But I think it's already very apparent that she has considerable doubts about Andrew's character, and whether she even feels the same way about him anymore
I think she's pretty certain that he thought he was doing the right thing, at least for her. There's no love lost between him and Rebecca, they've never liked each other. Rebecca has always thought that Andrew wasn't good enough for Anna, and Andrew has always believed that Rebecca was a bad influence on Anna. So as far as the kidnapping was concerned Andrew would have been thinking solely about Anna's welfare. I think he really does love her, in his own way. But he's never grasped how important Rebecca is to her, and how hurtful it would be to her, for him to help Fitzgerald kidnap her. He really does believe that getting her away from Rebecca will be positive for her in the long run. And that's a further demonstration, that he doesn't really see Anna as she really is. He has this perfect view of her, that most of the time doesn't bear any relation to reality. And that's why it was so easy for Anna to cheat on him, because often he never sees stuff that contradicts his idealised view of her.
Also, you have to understand, it's only been a short period of time that Anna has had these doubts. All of the events in this game, have taken place in a five week period. And she's only really had doubts for the last 2-3 weeks. But she's been in a relationship with Andrew for years, and until recently I think she fully expected to eventually become his wife and have kids with him. So she's not going to just drop all of that instantly, it's going to take her time to get used to the idea, that in most scenarios that isn't going to happen.
For me his part in the kidnapping, was just further confirmation that him and Anna were just totally unsuited. It didn't surprise me at all, that Andrew behaved the way that he did. But having said that, I've always been of the opinion that he should remain in the game. I may not like him at all, but I still think he has a part to play, as long as it doesn't stop Anna's adventures. And of course he wont. He never would have, even if Deep hadn't decided to put him in a coma. Because he was always going to be the fall guy. His primary purpose in the game, was to be the person that Anna cheated on.
And now there's a further reason why he has to remain in the game. And that's because the Devs have decided, that eventually he will get a renaissance route. A chance to make changes to his personality and win Anna back. How exactly they're intending to make someone virtually everyone hates, into a likeable character, I have no idea. But they insist this is something they're are seriously considering. And for that reason, Andrew has to remain in the game, even if he spends a lot of it unconscious.
