5.00 star(s) 1 Vote

NukaCola

Forum Fanatic
Jul 1, 2017
4,001
4,766
I gotta say, I don't think the criticism you guys are giving is fair. Given the fact that we're seeing a new (~3-5m) animation about every 2 months, and with the complexity of animations involved, its pretty good work all around.

What specifically makes ATD unique is the fact that the scenarios are completely visual (and sometimes abstract). The lack of voice work and sound effects are a defining characteristic of the art, not a missing component. Think about it, there's no other NSFW artist out there that produces anything like this.

I would argue that it would be worse off if it had voice work/sfx, you guys would be on the other end of the spectrum saying things like 'her whiney whimpering Japanese voice while getting fucked is annoying' <- which you all KNOW it would be. Or 'why does this still look like early 2000s quality rendering?!?' - its a stylistic choice, let it be. If you can do better, than go download Blender and see how easy it is to churn this kind of work, because anyone can tell you.. it ain't.

Appreciate it for what it is. Think of it as an appetizer to hold you over while you all wait a whole year for Wildeer to produce another Lara Croft iteration, or Jackerman to push another 'uncanny-valley-balloon-tit-incest' animation, or HydraFXX to make another 12s clip you can't fap to. Perspective people.
Except before he used to make like 8-10 minute animation a month. And with complex mutiple different scene. Now its just one scene with different angle for 3-4 minute. Take his last "good" animations for example. Alice G03 and Frost 12. They are both 7-8 minute long and have interesting different scenes.
 
Last edited:

Gabe-A

Newbie
May 7, 2024
15
38
Searching for an ATD animation. Is the "Phi Capture1" animation from the "ATD Subscribestar GOLD BOX" Mega link from years ago a completed animation? I saw a snippet of it in a video. Tried searching DLSite, Patreon and Pixiv. No dice. The monster is called "Smile monster" I guess. The girl is called Phi?
 

sgt_bilko

Member
Aug 16, 2018
456
3,704
Except before he used to make like 8-10 minute animation a month. And with complex mutiple different scene. Now its just one scene with different angle for 3-4 minute. Take his last "good" animations for example. Alice G03 and Frost 12. They are both 7-minute long and have interesting different scenes.
You just demonstrated my argument. You basically just said it went from 'fantastic' to just 'good.' 8-10m animations a month.... again.. that's fucking unprecedented compared to some of the other popular creators here. You got too comfortable with that release schedule and now you're crying because its not amazing anymore. It's still good. You don't know what's going on this guy's life, you don't know what demons he's wrestling with, so stop whining.

I'll refer again to the likes of Wildeer. A fucking YEAR.. it took that guy to produce a new animation. Kamadeva, RadeonG3D, Nyl... all haven't released anything since 2024.. Jackerman/Nagoonimation since January.. how many more examples do I need to throw out before you connect the dots?
 

atd520

Newbie
Feb 17, 2022
53
209
You just demonstrated my argument. You basically just said it went from 'fantastic' to just 'good.' 8-10m animations a month.... again.. that's fucking unprecedented compared to some of the other popular creators here. You got too comfortable with that release schedule and now you're crying because its not amazing anymore. It's still good. You don't know what's going on this guy's life, you don't know what demons he's wrestling with, so stop whining.

I'll refer again to the likes of Wildeer. A fucking YEAR.. it took that guy to produce a new animation. Kamadeva, RadeonG3D, Nyl... all haven't released anything since 2024.. Jackerman/Nagoonimation since January.. how many more examples do I need to throw out before you connect the dots?
Your point of view touched me. Everyone's life is diverse. We can't see it, so we can't understand it. We don't know what dilemma he is facing. The decline in quality of recent works is obvious, from texture to detail is a perfunctory attitude that followers can understand, but it is very rare for the author to keep updating all the time. We should give more tolerance and understanding instead of complaining.
 

Gabe-A

Newbie
May 7, 2024
15
38
Searching for an ATD animation. Is the "Phi Capture1" animation from the "ATD Subscribestar GOLD BOX" Mega link from years ago a completed animation? I saw a snippet of it in a video. Tried searching DLSite, Patreon and Pixiv. No dice. The monster is called "Smile monster" I guess. The girl is called Phi?
Cont. It's the same monster as in the Alice Spin Off video. The information I have found points me in the direction of Bio Seeker Phi-D9. The only files I have been able to find are the BIOD9_VRFIGHT ones from the individual download link, but they do not have the scene in question. It would seem that the bob cut girl (Alice?) is a part of the video I am looking for. There is a BIO 進捗2 named file in one of the earlier MEGA collection links that points to multiple scenes that are not in the Bio Seeker Phi-D9 set of videos in the individual download MEGA collection. Is there a full video somewhere else that I have not been able to find? Any help will be much appreciated.
 

ndfnk

Newbie
Apr 26, 2018
24
16
i agree that ATD's quality has dropped significantly. but more than anything, i think it's because it's rushed. people demand updates or new content every month, while production wise it's probably not to the artist's best interest. personally i would like it if ATD just take his time, and upload a long animation banger once every few months.
 

jaimd

Newbie
Jan 6, 2019
90
94
Except before he used to make like 8-10 minute animation a month. And with complex mutiple different scene. Now its just one scene with different angle for 3-4 minute. Take his last "good" animations for example. Alice G03 and Frost 12. They are both 7-8 minute long and have interesting different scenes.
And previously he voiced his animation with evem proper music, now he dowsnt do that so its not a form of art but rather cheaping out animation coat, even other creators who are solo animators like him can post with higher fidelity like ambient music / voice acting and its true current animations are so short
 

jaimd

Newbie
Jan 6, 2019
90
94
i agree that ATD's quality has dropped significantly. but more than anything, i think it's because it's rushed. people demand updates or new content every month, while production wise it's probably not to the artist's best interest. personally i would like it if ATD just take his time, and upload a long animation banger once every few months.
Id rather wait two months, see how nullstudio does,as long as updates are posted people will keep supporting even if there is no actual animation in a month, nullstudio for example post a full animation once evwry 6 months minimum and people still supoort him monthly even when his sound design with va is horrendous
 
  • Like
Reactions: ndfnk

Cotoko

Newbie
Jun 11, 2019
15
177
The author is too lazy to have quality products from previous years until now. However, many people still continue to support this laziness.
 
5.00 star(s) 1 Vote