Let me start by saying that I would have given this a 5 right until the ending.
The story kept me interested, the characters were mostly believable (and likeable) and the story was good enough that you became invested.
Also, I followed the "Patreon horny" walkthrough to see if my wrong choices were the cause of what I feel was a fucking shit ending. But nope. I would have put this near the top of my list, but the ending puts it at the bottom which is odd because I enjoyed it alllllll the fucking way there.
Graphics opinions:
I will also say that graphics have pretty much zero weight in my reviews. Im reviewing the story/gameplay, not the models.
I can deal with shitty graphics (lets face it, most of these have ugly faces, or just ugly or insanely unrealistic girls). I will say that the girls faces seemed much worse in the start than they did in the last half. I feel the author was able to fix whatever they were doing wrong.
Example of the face early on (bottom right) and how she looks later (I dont think the face really changed, I think the poses/angles/something changed but whatever it is it helped a lot)
Also last minute edit. The name is HORRIBLE. Im not sure about other countries, but here in the US, "babysitting" is something that is done for children 13 and under. From 14-18, if you have a babysitter, you are a very very bad or untrusted child. So I almost skipped this entirely because the name was very misleading. I dont feel like there is ANY babysitting or babysitters in this story at all.
More Edits: I just talked to some people on discord and found there is apparently a much better ending that I was unable to get. When I had issues making bad choices (that seemed good) I followed the walkthrough (both paths). I will say that my rating stands because even with the walkthrough I was not able to get a path I enjoyed and I should not need a walkthrough in the first place.
2023 edit (replaying):
I didnt mention it before, but the reason I had issues before was that I chose the horny route and not the friendship route. Because of the wording, I did not understand that the "friendship" route is the one where you guys stay together. To me, friendship means no fucking, no dating, etc.
I decided to give this game another go. One thing I am noticing that I didnt really notice before (or maybe I just didnt care) is that starting around day 7, the writing goes way downhill. Or maybe more accurately, the wording. My guess would be that from day 1-7 the dev had an actual native english speaker to translate or fix the text, but after that.... yeah. I can no longer help but read all dialog in a horrible russian accent in my head. I'm not sure I am going to be able to finish it because the crap russian accent my mind is trying to put on all of the dialog is really shitty and does not match any of the characters. Some examples:
"Probably we should change a topic here."
"Christine quickly changes into her gym clothes and takes the bus to
meet the Jessica at Haven park."
"
The Christine leaves the hot tub..."
"You went to the bedroom to pick up your phone and returned back to
the Christine. On the way back you called your friend Tommy..."
"Christine turns around as she realize that they haven't scrubbed their legs yet. At the same time they try to lean forward to
wash their own legs what ends in pushing Jessica's breast into
the Christine's face."
"Over the music
the Christine hears loud crash. She looks over and sees a bunch of people bowling nearby."
"Jessica waves at
the Christine and Robert."
"You get the to the balcony while following
the Christine and Jessica... but then you stop..."
"You and Christine make out some more.
The Christine seems to like it, but you feel like you could be pushing things ahead more."
"Christine quickly changes into her gym clothes and takes the bus to meet
the Jessica at Haven park."
"Robert leaves.
Christine walks over the Jessica."
"The girls get out of the shower and head to
the Jessica's room."
"Silver looks at
the Jessica again..."
"Christine puts her arm towards
the Jessica face and acts like she's using the force..."
"You grab a beer for you
and drink for the Jessica at the bar."
"Later,
the Jessisa is getting her hair cut."
"
Because probably Robert's girlfriend came there and she started swearing..."
"
you are freak into healthy style and you want to be a journalist."
"
I go to the bathroom to get the water started.
Waiting you there."
"You wave on
the Alyssa...
she quickly pass by with grin on her face..."
Then, before starting my new playthrough, I went through the walkthrough. And ran into the same issue as before. Very confusing. There is a "Corporate Route" and a "Patreon Route" (which is labelled as a "horny route"). Apparently the Corp route is the friendship route (which again, sounds like you would end as friends, not lovers). The entire walkthrough just gives me a headache. I feel this also could have been better done by someone who was a native english speaker.