Jarulf

White Knight
Donor
Aug 9, 2020
2,378
4,748
414
It's been a while since I've played this game, but I'm pretty sure that Ellie is always blood-related to MC through their father (the only difference is whether she's his full- or half-sister, depending on version) and, with her being the main heroine, I'd say it very much counts as an incest story.
Different mothers, that's clearly stated. But to be perfectly honest, I don't remember if Ellie's father is the same as the MC's. Was it left a bit vague perhaps?
I should have been a little more careful how I phrased things in previous post.
 

Master of Puppets

Conversation Conqueror
Oct 5, 2017
7,735
10,460
934
Sort of? But after the father died they weren't related as step anythings anymore
so the story was 'messed up' from the beginning???

Just musing...not trying to be argumentative...

---------

I'm an old fart....however several years back when my father kicked the bucket it took
several years before I realized they weren't my 'steps' anymore. Was the weirdest revelation
I ever had...lol Just woke up and realized I wasn't related to a bunch of folks anymore... lol
(She's still my momma though...)
I don't see that stepfamily stop being family if your blood mother/father dies anymore than the rest of your family does. You're only related to the rest of your family through your parents too. If your father dies, his brothers and sisters don't stop being your aunts and uncles, and his parents don't stop being your grandparents if they are still around.
 

jaw1986baby

Chasing Redhead sm0ls
Donor
Jun 2, 2017
2,566
7,668
742
I don't see that stepfamily stop being family if your blood mother/father dies anymore than the rest of your family does. You're only related to the rest of your family through your parents too. If your father dies, his brothers and sisters don't stop being your aunts and uncles, and his parents don't stop being your grandparents if they are still around.
She was never step anything

She was only a fuck toy and punching bag for the dead father. Never married. Never stepmom. Ellie was always blood related to MC. The "patch" for this one is super duper DUMB!
 

lnomsim

Active Member
Sep 12, 2021
921
1,419
296
She was never step anything

She was only a fuck toy and punching bag for the dead father. Never married. Never stepmom. Ellie was always blood related to MC. The "patch" for this one is super duper DUMB!
depending on the state they are, they could have been in a common law marriage.
 

Forgotted

Engaged Member
Sep 1, 2020
2,560
2,399
479
She was never step anything

She was only a fuck toy and punching bag for the dead father. Never married. Never stepmom. Ellie was always blood related to MC. The "patch" for this one is super duper DUMB!
So Ellie is a half sister
C2.PNG

Rachel isn't any relation.

MC was only gone 6 years.
C3.PNG

Cheers
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tyrannicpuppy

Forgotted

Engaged Member
Sep 1, 2020
2,560
2,399
479
The MC talking about being gone for so many years makes me think
that I moved away like that as well. Went back for a visit ~12 or so years later and was
truly surprised how 'almost' lost I got several times... lol Wasn't even that big... 40k people....
 
  • Like
Reactions: A.K.A87

jaw1986baby

Chasing Redhead sm0ls
Donor
Jun 2, 2017
2,566
7,668
742
depending on the state they are, they could have been in a common law marriage.
So Ellie is a half sister then?
and Rachel isn't any relation. (other than possible common law as Inomsim suggested but I'd expect that's outside
the scope of this game...)

Sorry, just got to that part after restarting...lol
Haven't found how many years the mc has been gone.
(just seems really dumb that he stops and stares at Ellie goin duh..wonder
if I know her from somewhere....)

Cheers
Very few US States do that and they do not do it against the will of the parties. No one asked to be married, so no one was married. Also it may well be a NON-USA location since the dev is German.
 

Forgotted

Engaged Member
Sep 1, 2020
2,560
2,399
479
Very few US States do that and they do not do it against the will of the parties. No one asked to be married, so no one was married. Also it may well be a NON-USA location since the dev is German.
Damn....that could get pretty dicey if you lived w a few different women over the years!
lol How many wives?
 

storm1105

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
798
1,571
358
Course...on the other hand, calling her a step mom doesn't make sense either, lol
She was never step anything

She was only a fuck toy and punching bag for the dead father. Never married. Never stepmom. Ellie was always blood related to MC. The "patch" for this one is super duper DUMB!
Eh, I think calling characters stepmoms are fine when they fit the role as a stepmom. Even if they were never officially married to the mc's father being their father's long time girlfriend and mother of the mc's half siblings is good enough to use the term stepmom. For all intents and purposes she is the mc's step mom she was just never officially married. She was also the mc's legal guardian after his father died
 
4.30 star(s) 216 Votes