Yeah, I completed first encounter. Firstly, I gave letter to Father and then give power & safe passage letter to Baralis. And then, I choose full food provision path. And I didn't get any potion mission.
When on doubt, read the journal. It will tell you to report to Irena. That opens the "final" options to handle him. After that, what to do depends a lot in the choice you make to solve penketh. But if you have explored around, you should have more clues about what is needed in the journal. the potion with him for example,
. If not, you deal with someone else. Things change a lot depending on your choice so...
The thing is: where to get the wine to befriend him enough, since the game doesnt allow you to go to Hartlepool, unless Penketh is done. Or I have missed something?
Finishing chapter 1 and be allowed to travel to hartlepool doesn't mean that you cannot get more goodies if come back to penketh and gain more affinity.
(Man, walktrought is so much easy if you
)
But as said, in 0.25 there will be more options to finish Penketh, as is a point where players get more confused. You'll also be able to travel to more places during chapter 1.