What I liked, in no particular order: the party planning minigame; how cool Zoey was and the longing looks she sometimes gives you; Sage's charm; Lily's awesome costume; the interactions with Heather and Sally; the replayability due to the different paths and the fact that the girls are still nice and pleasant even when not on their path; how well I felt I could connect with Bella; seeing how much Josy would like you to be together when not on her path; the overall atmosphere of the party.
I'm pretty sure there are other things I liked but it's midnight and I'm sleepy
There were a lot of things I also didn't like, but the worst to me were:
1) not being able to at least kiss Zoey (don't tell me it's still too awkward between them, they're horny teenagers at a party and they have booze at their disposal); to me, this is clearly milking by the dev - next episode you kiss, then in 2024 you get a blowjob, then in 2025 you did what you've already done years before.
2) not being able to beat Vinny (I played the DIK path last and was excited to get to the scene where I could finally pick the punch option... imagine my disappointment); if I could I would pull out his spine, like in Predator - he deserves it for also being a danger to Quinn and the Pink Rose girls.